Shop by Department
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor

Metal | Surplus Network

Set of 4 Martha Stewart By Mail Copper Cookie Cutters BAT OWL MOON & STAR
USA
Set of 4 Martha Stewart By Mail...

$220.00 USD

Set of 4 Martha Stewart By Mail...

$220.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Country Living ~ Bonne ~ Pumpkin #2
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$65.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$65.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Country Living ~ Bonne ~Wide Pumpkin
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$65.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$65.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Either a Flower or a Dove
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$125.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$125.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Martha Stewart by Mail~ Michael Bonne ~ Bauble
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$125.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$125.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Michael Bonne ~ Ornament?
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$125.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$125.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Martha Stewart by Mail ~ Bonne ~Snowflake Set
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$225.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$225.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Old River Road ~ Carrot
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Old...

$135.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Old...

$135.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Old River Road ~ Starfish
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Old...

$135.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Old...

$135.00 USD

Set of Four Vintage Train Tin Cookie Cutters Engine Caboose W Roberts
USA
Set of Four Vintage Train Tin Cookie...

$18.00 USD

Set of Four Vintage Train Tin Cookie...

$18.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Cape Cod Copper Works ~ Apple
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$50.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$50.00 USD

RARE Very Large Copper Cookie Cutter or Pan ~ Michael Bonne ~ Gingerbread Man
USA
RARE Very Large Copper Cookie Cutter...

$75.00 USD

RARE Very Large Copper Cookie Cutter...

$75.00 USD

RARE Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Michael Bonne ~ Small House
USA
RARE Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Michael...

$45.00 USD

RARE Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Michael...

$45.00 USD

RARE Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Michael Bonne ~ Star
USA
RARE Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Michael...

$45.00 USD

RARE Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Michael...

$45.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~ Simon
USA
RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$195.00 USD

RARE Large Copper Cookie Cutter ~...

$195.00 USD

Martha Stewart by Mail Baby Copper Cookie Cutter Set
USA
Martha Stewart by Mail Baby Copper...

$150.00 USD

Martha Stewart by Mail Baby Copper...

$150.00 USD

LOT of 9 aluminum cookie cutters Vintage moon man diamond bell star tree flower
USA
LOT of 9 aluminum cookie cutters...

$10.00 USD

LOT of 9 aluminum cookie cutters...

$10.00 USD

Vintage VIKING Handmade JAPAN 1950
USA
Vintage VIKING Handmade JAPAN 1950's...

$10.00 USD

Vintage VIKING Handmade JAPAN 1950's...

$10.00 USD

Martha by Mail Martha Stewart Halloween Cutter Set 2 Excellent Condition
USA
Martha by Mail Martha Stewart...

$69.00 USD

Martha by Mail Martha Stewart...

$69.00 USD

Vintage Cookie Cutter Large 5" Nut Tree Pickup TRAIN Car Vehicle Made in Sweden
USA
Vintage Cookie Cutter Large 5" Nut...

$27.00 USD

Vintage Cookie Cutter Large 5" Nut...

$27.00 USD

Tin Metal OWL Folk Art Cookie Cutter With Handle Horman Foose
USA
Tin Metal OWL Folk Art Cookie Cutter...

$20.00 USD

Tin Metal OWL Folk Art Cookie Cutter...

$20.00 USD

SIX Trudeau Yellow Silicone Reversible Egg Ring round square
USA
SIX Trudeau Yellow Silicone...

$20.00 USD

SIX Trudeau Yellow Silicone...

$20.00 USD

FANCYFLOURS SET OF 12 DAYS OF CHRISTMAS COPPER ECRANDAL COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
FANCYFLOURS SET OF 12 DAYS OF...

$269.99 USD

FANCYFLOURS SET OF 12 DAYS OF...

$269.99 USD

Lot 35 Vintage Cookie Cutters Christmas Gingerbread Man Shapes Hand Foot
USA
Lot 35 Vintage Cookie Cutters...

$15.44 USD

Lot 35 Vintage Cookie Cutters...

$15.44 USD

Vintage Large DEER WITH ANTLERS Metal Flat Back Cookie Cutter
USA
Vintage Large DEER WITH ANTLERS Metal...

$52.00 USD

Vintage Large DEER WITH ANTLERS Metal...

$52.00 USD

vintage thanksgiving pilgrim metal cookie cutters
USA
vintage thanksgiving pilgrim metal...

$7.99 USD

vintage thanksgiving pilgrim metal...

$7.99 USD

Vintage Monopol Auro Ges Gesch Metal and Wood Cookie Roller - Germany
USA
Vintage Monopol Auro Ges Gesch Metal...

$7.99 USD

Vintage Monopol Auro Ges Gesch Metal...

$7.99 USD

HUTZLER COOKIE CUT-UPS COOKIE CUTTERS 10 pc
USA
HUTZLER COOKIE CUT-UPS COOKIE CUTTERS...

$7.99 USD

HUTZLER COOKIE CUT-UPS COOKIE CUTTERS...

$7.99 USD

NIP Buddy The Elf Christmas Cookie Cutter
USA
NIP Buddy The Elf Christmas Cookie...

$9.99 USD

NIP Buddy The Elf Christmas Cookie...

$9.99 USD

Vintage ENSAR Halloween Cookie Cutters New In Package! Witch Ghost JackOLantern
USA
Vintage ENSAR Halloween Cookie...

$9.99 USD

Vintage ENSAR Halloween Cookie...

$9.99 USD

LOT OF 8 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTERS JOL WITCH BAT GHOST VAMPIRE BUZZARD
USA
LOT OF 8 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE...

$9.99 USD

LOT OF 8 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE...

$9.99 USD

Vintage Lot x3 Halloween Cookie Cutters 5" Witch On Broom~Cat~Jack-O-Lantern 
USA
Vintage Lot x3 Halloween Cookie...

$9.99 USD

Vintage Lot x3 Halloween Cookie...

$9.99 USD

Lot of 24 (2 Dozen) Vintage Metal Cookie & Biscuit Cutters Some with Handles
USA
Lot of 24 (2 Dozen) Vintage Metal...

$9.99 USD

Lot of 24 (2 Dozen) Vintage Metal...

$9.99 USD

12 Copper Tone Aluminum Cookie Cutter Angel Gingerbread Turkey Camel Scottie +
USA
12 Copper Tone Aluminum Cookie Cutter...

$15.95 USD

12 Copper Tone Aluminum Cookie Cutter...

$15.95 USD

Christmas Aluminum Cookie Cutters Vintage Lot of 17
USA
Christmas Aluminum Cookie Cutters...

$14.99 USD

Christmas Aluminum Cookie Cutters...

$14.99 USD

Antique Primitive Soldered Tin STANDING HORSE Cookie Cutter, Hand Made
USA
Antique Primitive Soldered Tin...

$14.99 USD

Antique Primitive Soldered Tin...

$14.99 USD

Vtg Rosette & Timbale Handle 4 Forms Card Suit Heart Club Diamond Spade FreeShip
USA
Vtg Rosette & Timbale Handle 4 Forms...

$14.99 USD

Vtg Rosette & Timbale Handle 4 Forms...

$14.99 USD

Vintage Aunt Chick 7 Red Plastic Cookie Cutters 4 are Christmas 3 are Flowers
USA
Vintage Aunt Chick 7 Red Plastic...

$14.99 USD

Vintage Aunt Chick 7 Red Plastic...

$14.99 USD

Great Halloween baking lot! Monster & Halloween cookie cutters, pumpkin muffin +
USA
Great Halloween baking lot! Monster &...

$27.99 USD

Great Halloween baking lot! Monster &...

$27.99 USD

4 Piece Vintage Hallmark Thanksgiving Cookie Cutters 1970
USA
4 Piece Vintage Hallmark Thanksgiving...

$19.00 USD

4 Piece Vintage Hallmark Thanksgiving...

$19.00 USD

Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters with handles 4 Angel Wants Reindeer & Holly 1960’s
USA
Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters with...

$8.99 USD

Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters with...

$8.99 USD

6 Vintage, Red, Plastic, Nursery Rhyme Party Set, Cookie Cutters, Forms, HRM
USA
6 Vintage, Red, Plastic, Nursery...

$12.16 USD

6 Vintage, Red, Plastic, Nursery...

$12.16 USD

Vintage Metal ROCKING HORSE Flat Back Folk Art Cookie Cutter
USA
Vintage Metal ROCKING HORSE Flat Back...

$34.00 USD

Vintage Metal ROCKING HORSE Flat Back...

$34.00 USD

Yale / Capac Mi Mich Michigan, Wollen Mills
USA
Yale / Capac Mi Mich Michigan, ...

$19.99 USD

Yale / Capac Mi Mich Michigan, ...

$19.99 USD

Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters, Lot of 23 Assorted - Some Wooden & Metal Handles
USA
Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters, Lot of...

$12.00 USD

Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters, Lot of...

$12.00 USD

vintage tupperware cookie/biscuit cutters
USA
vintage tupperware cookie/biscuit...

$12.00 USD

vintage tupperware cookie/biscuit...

$12.00 USD

Vintage Lot Tin(?)Tiny Cat, Bunny, Lion-Cookie Cutters With Handle Look!
USA
Vintage Lot Tin(?)Tiny Cat, Bunny,...

$12.00 USD

Vintage Lot Tin(?)Tiny Cat, Bunny,...

$12.00 USD

Vintage Oxwall 6 inch Side Cutters New in Original Box
USA
Vintage Oxwall 6 inch Side Cutters...

$12.00 USD

Vintage Oxwall 6 inch Side Cutters...

$12.00 USD

Lot of 6 Vintage Wilson 1970s Sesame Street Cookie Cutters Play-Doh.
USA
Lot of 6 Vintage Wilson 1970s Sesame...

$12.00 USD

Lot of 6 Vintage Wilson 1970s Sesame...

$12.00 USD

Vintage 12 Twelve Days Of Christmas Cookie Cutter Set 1978 Chilton Kraft Plastic
USA
Vintage 12 Twelve Days Of Christmas...

$13.50 USD

Vintage 12 Twelve Days Of Christmas...

$13.50 USD

Vintage Gingerbread Man Cookie Cutter
USA
Vintage Gingerbread Man Cookie Cutter

$7.50 USD

Vintage Gingerbread Man Cookie Cutter

$7.50 USD

2 Vintage Shear Genuine Tupperware Rocker Scoops #292
USA
2 Vintage Shear Genuine Tupperware...

$14.90 USD

2 Vintage Shear Genuine Tupperware...

$14.90 USD

Vintage Large Tin Metal GINGERBREAD MAN Flat Back Folk Art Cookie Cutter
USA
Vintage Large Tin Metal GINGERBREAD...

$60.00 USD

Vintage Large Tin Metal GINGERBREAD...

$60.00 USD

Vintage Bonnie Sealer Red Wooden Handle
USA
Vintage Bonnie Sealer Red Wooden Handle

$4.99 USD

Vintage Bonnie Sealer Red Wooden Handle

$4.99 USD

3 Vintage HALLOWEEN Fall COOKIE CUTTER Turkey witch spider web
USA
3 Vintage HALLOWEEN Fall COOKIE...

$4.99 USD

3 Vintage HALLOWEEN Fall COOKIE...

$4.99 USD

Norwegian Danish Swedish Gnome Elf Tomte Cookie Cutter #186E
USA
Norwegian Danish Swedish Gnome Elf...

$8.50 USD

Norwegian Danish Swedish Gnome Elf...

$8.50 USD

HRM Vintage Design Red Plastic Cookie Cutter - Christmas Poinsettia Bloom Nature
USA
HRM Vintage Design Red Plastic Cookie...

$8.25 USD

HRM Vintage Design Red Plastic Cookie...

$8.25 USD

Lot 6 Vtg 1978 Warner Bros Looney Tunes Cartoon Orange Plastic Cookie Cutter
USA
Lot 6 Vtg 1978 Warner Bros Looney...

$17.50 USD

Lot 6 Vtg 1978 Warner Bros Looney...

$17.50 USD

Set of 2 Vintage EKCO Metal Cookie Cutters Boy Girl Baker
USA
Set of 2 Vintage EKCO Metal Cookie...

$6.98 USD

Set of 2 Vintage EKCO Metal Cookie...

$6.98 USD

Sweet Creations Bunny Butt Cutter Set Cookie Cutter Set Easter
USA
Sweet Creations Bunny Butt Cutter Set...

$9.60 USD

Sweet Creations Bunny Butt Cutter Set...

$9.60 USD

Martha By Mail Vintage “Capital M Bee” Logo 6 Leaves Copper Cookie Cutters/Box
USA
Martha By Mail Vintage “Capital M...

$185.00 USD

Martha By Mail Vintage “Capital M...

$185.00 USD

LARGE Metal Cookie Cutters ~ Lot of 21 ~ Nice Variety ~ Buy it Now
USA
LARGE Metal Cookie Cutters ~ Lot of...

$5.00 USD

LARGE Metal Cookie Cutters ~ Lot of...

$5.00 USD

Aunt Chicks Vintage Red Plastic Cookie Cutter / Mold- Bunny Rabbit w/ Egg Easter
USA
Aunt Chicks Vintage Red Plastic...

$12.25 USD

Aunt Chicks Vintage Red Plastic...

$12.25 USD

Lot of 10 Vintage Copper Color Aluminum Cookie Cutters Holidays Animals Witch
USA
Lot of 10 Vintage Copper Color...

$14.85 USD

Lot of 10 Vintage Copper Color...

$14.85 USD

Antique Primitive Vintage Soldered Tin Handmade Wood Handle Cookie Cutter Lot
USA
Antique Primitive Vintage Soldered...

$19.95 USD

Antique Primitive Vintage Soldered...

$19.95 USD

Halloween Plastic Cookie Cutters Mixed Lot of 14
USA
Halloween Plastic Cookie Cutters...

$15.99 USD

Halloween Plastic Cookie Cutters...

$15.99 USD

Wilton Christmas Petite Cookie Cutter Set - Tree Star and Snowman
USA
Wilton Christmas Petite Cookie Cutter...

$6.95 USD

Wilton Christmas Petite Cookie Cutter...

$6.95 USD

Wilton: SHAMROCK COMFORT GRIP COOKIE CUTTER #2310-648 - New - 4 Inch -
USA
Wilton: SHAMROCK COMFORT GRIP COOKIE...

$6.95 USD

Wilton: SHAMROCK COMFORT GRIP COOKIE...

$6.95 USD

MARTHA STEWART BY MAIL Vintage Large "Snow Crystal" COPPER COOKIE CUTTER
USA
MARTHA STEWART BY MAIL Vintage Large...

$53.10 USD

MARTHA STEWART BY MAIL Vintage Large...

$53.10 USD

Vintage Nordic Wear Deluxe Cookie King Crank Type Press & Spritz Gun Made In USA
USA
Vintage Nordic Wear Deluxe Cookie...

$29.90 USD

Vintage Nordic Wear Deluxe Cookie...

$29.90 USD

Vintage Hallmark 80
USA
Vintage Hallmark 80's Turkey...

$5.99 USD

Vintage Hallmark 80's Turkey...

$5.99 USD

Vintage Hallmark 80
USA
Vintage Hallmark 80's Pilgrim Bird...

$5.99 USD

Vintage Hallmark 80's Pilgrim Bird...

$5.99 USD

Vintage Hallmark 70
USA
Vintage Hallmark 70's Halloween Witch...

$5.99 USD

Vintage Hallmark 70's Halloween Witch...

$5.99 USD

bunny cookie cutter 5 inch FREESHIP Easter rabbit spring
USA
bunny cookie cutter 5 inch FREESHIP...

$5.99 USD

bunny cookie cutter 5 inch FREESHIP...

$5.99 USD

Martha Stewart Prancing Reindeer & Snowflake Large Copper Cookie Cutters
USA
Martha Stewart Prancing Reindeer &...

$117.00 USD

Martha Stewart Prancing Reindeer &...

$117.00 USD

VINTAGE SET OF TWENTY-ONE ASSORTED METAL COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
VINTAGE SET OF TWENTY-ONE ASSORTED...

$12.99 USD

VINTAGE SET OF TWENTY-ONE ASSORTED...

$12.99 USD

Robin Hood Flour Plastic Cookie Cutters Hat Friar Tuck Maid Marian Castle Lot/6
USA
Robin Hood Flour Plastic Cookie...

$12.99 USD

Robin Hood Flour Plastic Cookie...

$12.99 USD

Boston Mountain Cookie Cutter Copper / shape of a House, 4 “ tall, heavy
USA
Boston Mountain Cookie Cutter Copper...

$5.50 USD

Boston Mountain Cookie Cutter Copper...

$5.50 USD

NEW!! DEEP CUT GIRL SCOUT/TREFOIL COOKIE CUTTER "DMWS"
USA
NEW!! DEEP CUT GIRL SCOUT/TREFOIL...

$6.00 USD

NEW!! DEEP CUT GIRL SCOUT/TREFOIL...

$6.00 USD

Vintage PA Primitive Folk Art Flat Back Tin Cookie Cutter - Guitar! - EUC!
USA
Vintage PA Primitive Folk Art Flat...

$6.00 USD

Vintage PA Primitive Folk Art Flat...

$6.00 USD

VTG Aluminum Cookie Cutter Turkey Thanksgiving Autumn Harvest 4x3.5x.25” Wonky!
USA
VTG Aluminum Cookie Cutter Turkey...

$3.95 USD

VTG Aluminum Cookie Cutter Turkey...

$3.95 USD

Vintage Soldered Tin Handmade Cookie Cutters Violin Fiddle Musical Note Cooke NC
USA
Vintage Soldered Tin Handmade Cookie...

$28.00 USD

Vintage Soldered Tin Handmade Cookie...

$28.00 USD

VINTAGE EXTRA Large Martha Stewart COPPER METAL Barnyard Hen FARM Cookie Cutter
USA
VINTAGE EXTRA Large Martha Stewart...

$39.99 USD

VINTAGE EXTRA Large Martha Stewart...

$39.99 USD

Martha Stewart - Nordstrom Large 7” Copper Teddy Bear Cookie Cutter
USA
Martha Stewart - Nordstrom Large 7”...

$24.00 USD

Martha Stewart - Nordstrom Large 7”...

$24.00 USD

Nordstrom Martha Stewart 7" Teddy Bear Copper Cookie Cutter In Original Box
USA
Nordstrom Martha Stewart 7" Teddy...

$35.00 USD

Nordstrom Martha Stewart 7" Teddy...

$35.00 USD

Lot Of 9 Vintage Cookie Cutters Christmas Holidays mixed brands
USA
Lot Of 9 Vintage Cookie Cutters...

$12.95 USD

Lot Of 9 Vintage Cookie Cutters...

$12.95 USD

Vintage 1940s-1950s Hutzler Plastic Cookie Cutters 14 Piece Set
USA
Vintage 1940s-1950s Hutzler Plastic...

$40.00 USD

Vintage 1940s-1950s Hutzler Plastic...

$40.00 USD

Vintage MARTHA STEWART Copper Cookie Cutter STAR LIGHT 8" Oversize MSL
USA
Vintage MARTHA STEWART Copper Cookie...

$40.00 USD

Vintage MARTHA STEWART Copper Cookie...

$40.00 USD

Vintage Mirro Cookie Press
USA
Vintage Mirro Cookie Press

$8.00 USD

Vintage Mirro Cookie Press

$8.00 USD

Lot 6 Hallmark cookie cutters Christmas Winter VINTAGE Snowman Angel Wreath
USA
Lot 6 Hallmark cookie cutters ...

$8.00 USD

Lot 6 Hallmark cookie cutters ...

$8.00 USD

Vintage Metal Cookie CuttersLot of 15
USA
Vintage Metal Cookie CuttersLot of 15

$34.70 USD

Vintage Metal Cookie CuttersLot of 15

$34.70 USD

LOT OF 2 TRUDEAU SILICONE POACHED CRACKED EGG HOLDER YELLOW APPROX 3.5" DIAMETER
USA
LOT OF 2 TRUDEAU SILICONE POACHED...

$9.96 USD

LOT OF 2 TRUDEAU SILICONE POACHED...

$9.96 USD

Martha By Mail Giant Copper Cookie Cutter Patriotic Set - Flag And Shield
USA
Martha By Mail Giant Copper Cookie...

$450.00 USD

Martha By Mail Giant Copper Cookie...

$450.00 USD

Ann Clark Flying Bat Cookie Cutter (Halloween Must-Have) ~~FREE SHIPPING~~ NEW
USA
Ann Clark Flying Bat Cookie Cutter ...

$3.99 USD

Ann Clark Flying Bat Cookie Cutter ...

$3.99 USD

Vintage Cookie Cutters Thanksgiving Fall Hutlzer Plastic Made in USA
USA
Vintage Cookie Cutters Thanksgiving...

$9.98 USD

Vintage Cookie Cutters Thanksgiving...

$9.98 USD

Vintage Metal Cookie Cutter Set Poker Bridge Cards Heart Diamond Club Spade Star
USA
Vintage Metal Cookie Cutter Set Poker...

$8.95 USD

Vintage Metal Cookie Cutter Set Poker...

$8.95 USD

Martha Stewart Living “BIG HEART” Copper Cookie Cutter Extra Large Pre-owned
USA
Martha Stewart Living “BIG HEART”...

$47.00 USD

Martha Stewart Living “BIG HEART”...

$47.00 USD

MARTHA STEWART BY MAIL Large HEART IN HAND Copper Cookie Cutter ~ FREE SHIPPING
USA
MARTHA STEWART BY MAIL Large HEART IN...

$69.95 USD

MARTHA STEWART BY MAIL Large HEART IN...

$69.95 USD

Martha Stewart Living Large Copper Teddy Bear Cookie Cutter Nordstrom On Handle
USA
Martha Stewart Living Large Copper...

$19.50 USD

Martha Stewart Living Large Copper...

$19.50 USD

New Rare Michael Bonne Solid Copper Whale Handmade Cookie Cutter Sealed
USA
New Rare Michael Bonne Solid Copper...

$89.95 USD

New Rare Michael Bonne Solid Copper...

$89.95 USD