Shop by Department
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor

Other Vintage Cookie Cutters | Surplus Network

Vintage BAUER Springerle Cookie Mold Carved Wood, 12 Designs, Cake-Art
USA
Vintage BAUER Springerle Cookie Mold...

$45.00 USD

Vintage BAUER Springerle Cookie Mold...

$45.00 USD

17 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters - Angel, Goose, Rabbit, Strawberry, More
USA
17 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters -...

$23.23 USD

17 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters -...

$23.23 USD

Vtg.Miniature Child
USA
Vtg.Miniature Child's Toy Aluminum...

$30.00 USD

Vtg.Miniature Child's Toy Aluminum...

$30.00 USD

Vintage Red Plastic Fortress Christmas Cookie Cutters NOS 12 Pc Manger Scene
USA
Vintage Red Plastic Fortress...

$34.99 USD

Vintage Red Plastic Fortress...

$34.99 USD

Vtg Speculaas Cookie Mold Wood Animal Carvings Block Owl Cat Fish Bird Feline
USA
Vtg Speculaas Cookie Mold Wood...

$49.43 USD

Vtg Speculaas Cookie Mold Wood...

$49.43 USD

Vintage Antique Christmas Tin Multi-Cookie Cutter BIN
USA
Vintage Antique Christmas Tin...

$150.00 USD

Vintage Antique Christmas Tin...

$150.00 USD

Ex Rare Antique 6 Animal Pennsylvania Cookie Cutter Ball Mold 19th Century 1869?
USA
Ex Rare Antique 6 Animal Pennsylvania...

$150.00 USD

Ex Rare Antique 6 Animal Pennsylvania...

$150.00 USD

RARE ANTIQUE PRIMITIVE RELIGIOUS HAND CARVED WOOD HEART SPRINGERLE / BREAD MOLD
USA
RARE ANTIQUE PRIMITIVE RELIGIOUS HAND...

$155.00 USD

RARE ANTIQUE PRIMITIVE RELIGIOUS HAND...

$155.00 USD

GREAT AMERICAN HOME BAKING Cookie Collection with Cutters, Recipe Cards
USA
GREAT AMERICAN HOME BAKING Cookie...

$15.00 USD

GREAT AMERICAN HOME BAKING Cookie...

$15.00 USD

NORDIC WARE 7pc Deluxe Rosette & Timbale Set
USA
NORDIC WARE 7pc Deluxe Rosette &...

$15.00 USD

NORDIC WARE 7pc Deluxe Rosette &...

$15.00 USD

Vintage Mirro Full Recipe Cooky Press in Box With Design Plates Cookie Press
USA
Vintage Mirro Full Recipe Cooky Press...

$15.00 USD

Vintage Mirro Full Recipe Cooky Press...

$15.00 USD

Vintage Wilton Cookie Cutters lot of 8 from 1990-2000 copper,tin,plastic
USA
Vintage Wilton Cookie Cutters lot of...

$15.00 USD

Vintage Wilton Cookie Cutters lot of...

$15.00 USD

Antique Rabbit Cookie Cutter; Flat Back; 3 1/2
USA
Antique Rabbit Cookie Cutter; Flat...

$15.00 USD

Antique Rabbit Cookie Cutter; Flat...

$15.00 USD

Nordic Ware Double Rosette Timbale Iron Two 4 Form Box
USA
Nordic Ware Double Rosette Timbale...

$15.00 USD

Nordic Ware Double Rosette Timbale...

$15.00 USD

Vintage Antique Wooden Hat Form - 17 LO 7 1/8 NUMBER 3
USA
Vintage Antique Wooden Hat Form - 17...

$34.95 USD

Vintage Antique Wooden Hat Form - 17...

$34.95 USD

4 Piece Vintage Red Plastic Cookie Cutters Santa, Stocking, Snowman, Pumpkin
USA
4 Piece Vintage Red Plastic Cookie...

$13.99 USD

4 Piece Vintage Red Plastic Cookie...

$13.99 USD

Vintage 1978 Chilton The Twelve Days Of Christmas Cookie Cutter 12ea lot of 2
USA
Vintage 1978 Chilton The Twelve Days...

$39.99 USD

Vintage 1978 Chilton The Twelve Days...

$39.99 USD

VINTAGE Set of Seven (7) Robin Hood Flour Plastic Cookie Cutters
USA
VINTAGE Set of Seven (7) Robin Hood...

$19.95 USD

VINTAGE Set of Seven (7) Robin Hood...

$19.95 USD

Assorted VINTAGE Tupperware Red Plastic Cookie Cutters
USA
Assorted VINTAGE Tupperware Red...

$19.95 USD

Assorted VINTAGE Tupperware Red...

$19.95 USD

GREAT Collection of 13 Vintage Metal & Plastic Christmas Cookie Cutters
USA
GREAT Collection of 13 Vintage Metal...

$19.95 USD

GREAT Collection of 13 Vintage Metal...

$19.95 USD

Vintage Hey Diddle Diddle Cookie Jar
USA
Vintage Hey Diddle Diddle Cookie Jar

$300.00 USD

Vintage Hey Diddle Diddle Cookie Jar

$300.00 USD

ANTIQUE B.W. SIEMONS AMSTERDAM GERMAN HAND CARVED WOOD COOKIE MOLD PATTERN
USA
ANTIQUE B.W. SIEMONS AMSTERDAM GERMAN...

$70.00 USD

ANTIQUE B.W. SIEMONS AMSTERDAM GERMAN...

$70.00 USD

Hallmark Cookie Cutters lot of 23
USA
Hallmark Cookie Cutters lot of 23

$10.00 USD

Hallmark Cookie Cutters lot of 23

$10.00 USD

Set of 8 Vintage Tupperware Cookie Cutters
USA
Set of 8 Vintage Tupperware Cookie...

$10.00 USD

Set of 8 Vintage Tupperware Cookie...

$10.00 USD

Vintage Assorted Hand Tools(5) Kitchen • Sewing • Assorted Brands• Estate Sale
USA
Vintage Assorted Hand Tools(5)...

$10.00 USD

Vintage Assorted Hand Tools(5)...

$10.00 USD

TUPPERWARE 8 IN 1 COOKIE CUTTER KIT INCLUDES HEART CLOVER MOON STAR IN BLUE CASE
USA
TUPPERWARE 8 IN 1 COOKIE CUTTER KIT...

$10.00 USD

TUPPERWARE 8 IN 1 COOKIE CUTTER KIT...

$10.00 USD

Vintage 1978 Chilton The Twelve Days Of Christmas Cookie Cutter Set of 12
USA
Vintage 1978 Chilton The Twelve Days...

$19.98 USD

Vintage 1978 Chilton The Twelve Days...

$19.98 USD

Antique Norwegian sugar cutter 1840-1900
Norway
Antique Norwegian sugar cutter 1840-1900

$190.00 USD

Antique Norwegian sugar cutter 1840-1900

$190.00 USD

Matching Pair Of Electric Brass Wall Mount Candle Holder Sconce
USA
Matching Pair Of Electric Brass Wall...

$39.95 USD

Matching Pair Of Electric Brass Wall...

$39.95 USD

Cookie Cutter Lot~Metal & Plastic~Christmas~Easter~Fairy Tale-Gingerbread People
USA
Cookie Cutter Lot~Metal &...

$32.50 USD

Cookie Cutter Lot~Metal &...

$32.50 USD

Mirro Aluminum Christmas Cookie Cooky Cutter Set S-3460-15 Sealed 5 pc Vintage
USA
Mirro Aluminum Christmas Cookie Cooky...

$24.95 USD

Mirro Aluminum Christmas Cookie Cooky...

$24.95 USD

Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters - HRM Wilton ++
USA
Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie...

$24.99 USD

Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie...

$24.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG WHITE SHORTBREAD COOKIE MOLD w/ hearts #1
USA
HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG WHITE...

$24.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG WHITE...

$24.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG BROWN SHORTBREAD COOKIE MOLD w/ hearts
USA
HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG BROWN...

$24.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG BROWN...

$24.99 USD

DEEP SPRING WHISKEY METAL SIGN - GREAT COLOR
USA
DEEP SPRING WHISKEY METAL SIGN -...

$29.95 USD

DEEP SPRING WHISKEY METAL SIGN -...

$29.95 USD

Antique 20 Nested Round Cookie Biscuit Cutters, Heavy Tin, Box w Lid
USA
Antique 20 Nested Round Cookie...

$29.95 USD

Antique 20 Nested Round Cookie...

$29.95 USD

Mirro Cooky Cutter Set No. S-3458-15 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters
USA
Mirro Cooky Cutter Set No. S-3458-15...

$18.95 USD

Mirro Cooky Cutter Set No. S-3458-15...

$18.95 USD

Vintage Round Tin Wooden Handle Biscuit Cutter
USA
Vintage Round Tin Wooden Handle...

$12.00 USD

Vintage Round Tin Wooden Handle...

$12.00 USD

Vintage Orange Tupperware Full Set of 5 Nesting Cookie/ Biscuit/ Canape Cutters
USA
Vintage Orange Tupperware Full Set of...

$14.00 USD

Vintage Orange Tupperware Full Set of...

$14.00 USD

14 Nested ROUND Biscuit Cutter set Made Italy cookie dough baking 3/4" - 4 1/2"
USA
14 Nested ROUND Biscuit Cutter set...

$20.00 USD

14 Nested ROUND Biscuit Cutter set...

$20.00 USD

Antique Tin Horse Cookie Cutter Flat Back Buy It Now
USA
Antique Tin Horse Cookie Cutter Flat...

$20.00 USD

Antique Tin Horse Cookie Cutter Flat...

$20.00 USD

Vintage Nordic Ware Double Rosette and Timbale Iron, Box & Instruction Included
USA
Vintage Nordic Ware Double Rosette...

$10.99 USD

Vintage Nordic Ware Double Rosette...

$10.99 USD

Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double Sided Cut Out Cutters, Round
USA
Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double...

$9.69 USD

Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double...

$9.69 USD

Vintage Raggedy Anne And Andy Plastic Kitchen Cookie Cutters Head Molds
USA
Vintage Raggedy Anne And Andy Plastic...

$5.99 USD

Vintage Raggedy Anne And Andy Plastic...

$5.99 USD

Hallmark Thanksgiving Fall Painted Plastic Cookie Cutter Scarecrow 4" x 3" Used
USA
Hallmark Thanksgiving Fall Painted...

$5.99 USD

Hallmark Thanksgiving Fall Painted...

$5.99 USD

Wilton Sesame Street BIG BIRD Ceramic Cookie Mold 2306-3461 1998 NEW
USA
Wilton Sesame Street BIG BIRD Ceramic...

$5.99 USD

Wilton Sesame Street BIG BIRD Ceramic...

$5.99 USD

VINTAGE 1978 Chilton 12 Twelve Days of Christmas COOKIE CUTTER SET Complete
USA
VINTAGE 1978 Chilton 12 Twelve Days...

$9.00 USD

VINTAGE 1978 Chilton 12 Twelve Days...

$9.00 USD

VINTAGE MIRRO COOKY-PASTRY KIT M-0358-22
USA
VINTAGE MIRRO COOKY-PASTRY KIT M-0358-22

$15.99 USD

VINTAGE MIRRO COOKY-PASTRY KIT M-0358-22

$15.99 USD

Vintage 10 Nested OVAL Biscuit Cutters - Made In Italy - Set of 10
USA
Vintage 10 Nested OVAL Biscuit...

$15.99 USD

Vintage 10 Nested OVAL Biscuit...

$15.99 USD

DACHSHUND DOG COPPER COOKIE CUTTER Extra Sturdy Metal with Handle Vintage
USA
DACHSHUND DOG COPPER COOKIE CUTTER...

$15.99 USD

DACHSHUND DOG COPPER COOKIE CUTTER...

$15.99 USD

Vintage 10 Nested OVAL Biscuit Cutters Italy Set of 10
USA
Vintage 10 Nested OVAL Biscuit...

$18.00 USD

Vintage 10 Nested OVAL Biscuit...

$18.00 USD

1998 Ethel Ammerman Halloween Witches Hat Tin Cookie Cutter 4.5"
USA
1998 Ethel Ammerman Halloween Witches...

$14.99 USD

1998 Ethel Ammerman Halloween Witches...

$14.99 USD

VINTAGE WILTON EASTER DECORATING SET Cookie Cutters Piping Bag Instructions 1978
USA
VINTAGE WILTON EASTER DECORATING SET...

$14.99 USD

VINTAGE WILTON EASTER DECORATING SET...

$14.99 USD

Vintage Old Fashioned Cookie Canapés Cutters 12 Pieces Assorted Holiday + Shapes
USA
Vintage Old Fashioned Cookie Canapés...

$14.99 USD

Vintage Old Fashioned Cookie Canapés...

$14.99 USD

2008 Cookie Cutter Collectors Club La Crosse, WI Cookie Stamp 4.5"
USA
2008 Cookie Cutter Collectors Club La...

$14.99 USD

2008 Cookie Cutter Collectors Club La...

$14.99 USD

set of 4 Clear Glass 2 1/2" Cookie Press Hearts flowers design NICE Vintage
USA
set of 4 Clear Glass 2 1/2" Cookie...

$17.77 USD

set of 4 Clear Glass 2 1/2" Cookie...

$17.77 USD

VTG LOT 22 COOKIE CUTTERS RED CLEAR PLASTIC-TUPPERWARE-GOLD TONE ALUMINUM
USA
VTG LOT 22 COOKIE CUTTERS RED CLEAR...

$19.99 USD

VTG LOT 22 COOKIE CUTTERS RED CLEAR...

$19.99 USD

Lot of 4 Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters Green Handles Wood Knob Biscuit Bunny Star
USA
Lot of 4 Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters...

$19.99 USD

Lot of 4 Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters...

$19.99 USD

vintage set of 6 Christmas Mary Ellen Plastic Holiday Cookie Cutters 4" NOS
USA
vintage set of 6 Christmas Mary Ellen...

$19.99 USD

vintage set of 6 Christmas Mary Ellen...

$19.99 USD

2 Vintage Large Heavy Duty Gauge Riveted Copper Cookie Cutters - Star & Tree
USA
2 Vintage Large Heavy Duty Gauge...

$19.99 USD

2 Vintage Large Heavy Duty Gauge...

$19.99 USD

Vintage HEART aluminum cookie cutter UNUSUAL BUTTERSCOTCH bakelite handle
USA
Vintage HEART aluminum cookie cutter...

$19.99 USD

Vintage HEART aluminum cookie cutter...

$19.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY Shortbread Cookie Mold decorated with strawberries
USA
HARTSTONE POTTERY Shortbread Cookie...

$19.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY Shortbread Cookie...

$19.99 USD

Brown Bag Cookie Shortbread Molds Vintage Watering Can Flowers/Angel/Rag Ann
USA
Brown Bag Cookie Shortbread Molds...

$32.99 USD

Brown Bag Cookie Shortbread Molds...

$32.99 USD

Vintage Lot Cookie Cutters Aluminum Metal Painted Wood Farmhouse Kitchen Antique
USA
Vintage Lot Cookie Cutters Aluminum...

$78.67 USD

Vintage Lot Cookie Cutters Aluminum...

$78.67 USD

Vintage Aluminum Unbranded Cookie Cutters 6 Lot Different Shapes & size 4"- 2.5"
USA
Vintage Aluminum Unbranded Cookie...

$9.99 USD

Vintage Aluminum Unbranded Cookie...

$9.99 USD

Animal Cookie Template Lion Large Cookie Cutter Copper Nice!
USA
Animal Cookie Template Lion Large...

$9.99 USD

Animal Cookie Template Lion Large...

$9.99 USD

Plastic with Silicone Grip Unbranded Cookie Cutter Shapes Pumpkin & Bat 4"- 3.5"
USA
Plastic with Silicone Grip Unbranded...

$9.99 USD

Plastic with Silicone Grip Unbranded...

$9.99 USD

Antique/Vintage Donut Cutter
USA
Antique/Vintage Donut Cutter

$5.00 USD

Antique/Vintage Donut Cutter

$5.00 USD

TREFOIL/ GIRL SCOUT COOKIE CUTTER -DMWS-
USA
TREFOIL/ GIRL SCOUT COOKIE CUTTER...

$5.00 USD

TREFOIL/ GIRL SCOUT COOKIE CUTTER...

$5.00 USD

2 Vintage Aluminum Green Handled Gingerbread Man and Chicken Cookie Cutters
USA
2 Vintage Aluminum Green Handled...

$5.00 USD

2 Vintage Aluminum Green Handled...

$5.00 USD

Vintage 1950s Mother Goose Cookie Cutters Set of 9 Plastic
USA
Vintage 1950s Mother Goose Cookie...

$23.49 USD

Vintage 1950s Mother Goose Cookie...

$23.49 USD

Antique Cookie Cutters - Set of 10 Red Wooden Handles
USA
Antique Cookie Cutters - Set of 10...

$29.99 USD

Antique Cookie Cutters - Set of 10...

$29.99 USD

Vintage Set of 6 Metal Cake & Sandwich Cookie Cutters Bridge Luncheons Party
USA
Vintage Set of 6 Metal Cake &...

$21.88 USD

Vintage Set of 6 Metal Cake &...

$21.88 USD

NEW BOXED Vtg. 6 METAL COOKY / COOKIE CUTTERS FOR EASTER Use for clay, cheese ++
USA
NEW BOXED Vtg. 6 METAL COOKY / COOKIE...

$12.99 USD

NEW BOXED Vtg. 6 METAL COOKY / COOKIE...

$12.99 USD

Vintage Cookie Maker and Decorating Press YP-701 w/ 18 Discs & Recipe Book
USA
Vintage Cookie Maker and Decorating...

$15.95 USD

Vintage Cookie Maker and Decorating...

$15.95 USD

Lot of 5 Vintage Aluminum Metal Cookie Cutters: Round, Spade, Hearts, Star
USA
Lot of 5 Vintage Aluminum Metal...

$4.49 USD

Lot of 5 Vintage Aluminum Metal...

$4.49 USD

Brown Bag Cookie Art 1989 Cookie Mold Hill Design Heart Flowers Tulips Baking
USA
Brown Bag Cookie Art 1989 Cookie Mold...

$9.98 USD

Brown Bag Cookie Art 1989 Cookie Mold...

$9.98 USD

Brand New - Tupperware Cookie Cutters Blue and Clear 5 pc
USA
Brand New - Tupperware Cookie Cutters...

$11.99 USD

Brand New - Tupperware Cookie Cutters...

$11.99 USD

Lot 8 Party Pooper Jelly Bean Dispenser Animals Pig Cat Moose Polar Bear Sheep
USA
Lot 8 Party Pooper Jelly Bean...

$26.99 USD

Lot 8 Party Pooper Jelly Bean...

$26.99 USD

Vintage 1975 Hallmark Joan Walsh Anglund Little Girl Cookie Cutter
USA
Vintage 1975 Hallmark Joan Walsh...

$4.00 USD

Vintage 1975 Hallmark Joan Walsh...

$4.00 USD

Lot of 14 Cookie Cutters - Hutzler Animals, Holidays, TPC Pillsbury Doughboy etc
USA
Lot of 14 Cookie Cutters - Hutzler...

$9.45 USD

Lot of 14 Cookie Cutters - Hutzler...

$9.45 USD

Great American Home Baking Cookie Collection Tin w Cookie Recipes on 5x7 cards
USA
Great American Home Baking Cookie...

$16.95 USD

Great American Home Baking Cookie...

$16.95 USD

Mirro Dial A Cookie Press, Aluminum Decorator , 9 Cookie Cutters And A Charles
USA
Mirro Dial A Cookie Press, Aluminum ...

$40.00 USD

Mirro Dial A Cookie Press, Aluminum ...

$40.00 USD

Set of 8 Vintage Red Tupperware Cookie Cutters Holidays With Recipe Card EUC
USA
Set of 8 Vintage Red Tupperware...

$8.00 USD

Set of 8 Vintage Red Tupperware...

$8.00 USD

Witch On Broom Cookie Cutter Vintage Silver Aluminum Handle Halloween Holiday
USA
Witch On Broom Cookie Cutter Vintage...

$8.00 USD

Witch On Broom Cookie Cutter Vintage...

$8.00 USD

LOT 29 Hallmark & Vintage Tupperware & More Cookie Cutters
USA
LOT 29 Hallmark & Vintage Tupperware...

$8.00 USD

LOT 29 Hallmark & Vintage Tupperware...

$8.00 USD

VINTAGE NORDIC WARE DOUBLE ROSETTE IRON & TIMBALE IRON PATTY SHELL No. 210B
USA
VINTAGE NORDIC WARE DOUBLE ROSETTE...

$29.00 USD

VINTAGE NORDIC WARE DOUBLE ROSETTE...

$29.00 USD

Tupperware 8 in 1 Cookie Cutters Set New Blue 3799 Sheer Acrylic Case
USA
Tupperware 8 in 1 Cookie Cutters Set...

$13.37 USD

Tupperware 8 in 1 Cookie Cutters Set...

$13.37 USD

Vintage Kalkus-Hirco Christmas Rosette Iron Set
USA
Vintage Kalkus-Hirco Christmas...

$49.99 USD

Vintage Kalkus-Hirco Christmas...

$49.99 USD

Lot of 6 Vintage HRM Red Plastic Christmas Cookie Cutters Santa Reindeer Drum
USA
Lot of 6 Vintage HRM Red Plastic...

$28.00 USD

Lot of 6 Vintage HRM Red Plastic...

$28.00 USD

Lot #7 Vintage Wood Handle Cookie Cutters Green Lot of 6
USA
Lot #7 Vintage Wood Handle Cookie...

$18.50 USD

Lot #7 Vintage Wood Handle Cookie...

$18.50 USD

Vtg 7 Tupperware Holiday Cookie Cutters Thanksgiving Halloween Easter Christmas
USA
Vtg 7 Tupperware Holiday Cookie...

$6.99 USD

Vtg 7 Tupperware Holiday Cookie...

$6.99 USD

Vtg aluminum metal cookie cutter Lot of 7 w/handles - Holiday & Poker Card Set
USA
Vtg aluminum metal cookie cutter Lot...

$10.95 USD

Vtg aluminum metal cookie cutter Lot...

$10.95 USD

Four (4) Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters with Handles
USA
Four (4) Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters...

$14.95 USD

Four (4) Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters...

$14.95 USD

German Design Rolling Christmas Cookie Cutters w 24 Holiday Cookie Cutters VTG
USA
German Design Rolling Christmas...

$12.98 USD

German Design Rolling Christmas...

$12.98 USD

🎄 Vintage red plastic Thanksgiving Tom Turkey bird Cookie Cutter shape handled
USA
🎄 Vintage red plastic Thanksgiving...

$2.95 USD

🎄 Vintage red plastic Thanksgiving...

$2.95 USD

Vintage Wilton Precious moments set of 8 plastic cookie cutters IOB
USA
Vintage Wilton Precious moments set...

$25.00 USD

Vintage Wilton Precious moments set...

$25.00 USD

GLORIOUS ANGEL 1997 Brown Bag Cookie Art Cookie Stamp Press
USA
GLORIOUS ANGEL 1997 Brown Bag Cookie...

$28.88 USD

GLORIOUS ANGEL 1997 Brown Bag Cookie...

$28.88 USD

VINTAGE 10 ROUND BISCUIT CUTTERS 5/8" TO 3" MADE IN ITALY
USA
VINTAGE 10 ROUND BISCUIT CUTTERS 5/8"...

$7.99 USD

VINTAGE 10 ROUND BISCUIT CUTTERS 5/8"...

$7.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY Brown Angel with Trumpet Cookie Mold
USA
HARTSTONE POTTERY Brown Angel with...

$12.50 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY Brown Angel with...

$12.50 USD