Shop by Department
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor

Other Vintage Cookie Cutters | Surplus Network

Martha by Mail Ring and Wedding cake cookie cutter NEW IN BOX
USA
Martha by Mail Ring and Wedding cake...

$265.00 USD

Martha by Mail Ring and Wedding cake...

$265.00 USD

⭐ Vtg Silver Holly leaf ⭐ metal aluminum Pastry ⭐ Xmas Cookie Cutter with handle
USA
⭐ Vtg Silver Holly leaf ⭐ metal...

$3.75 USD

⭐ Vtg Silver Holly leaf ⭐ metal...

$3.75 USD

Vintage Tupperware Set of Five ( 5 ) Nesting Cookie/Biscuit/Canape Cutters
USA
Vintage Tupperware Set of Five ( 5 )...

$4.95 USD

Vintage Tupperware Set of Five ( 5 )...

$4.95 USD

Smuckers Cookie Cutters Promo Giveaway Vintage Holiday Christmas Snowman Bell
USA
Smuckers Cookie Cutters Promo...

$8.00 USD

Smuckers Cookie Cutters Promo...

$8.00 USD

SET OF 9 VINTAGE ALUMINUM CHRISTMAS COOKIE CUTTERS EXCELLENT
USA
SET OF 9 VINTAGE ALUMINUM CHRISTMAS...

$8.00 USD

SET OF 9 VINTAGE ALUMINUM CHRISTMAS...

$8.00 USD

VTG Unused MINIATURE 2" Metal COOKIE CUTTERS Box XMAS CAT ~ Child Craft Play doh
USA
VTG Unused MINIATURE 2" Metal COOKIE...

$7.00 USD

VTG Unused MINIATURE 2" Metal COOKIE...

$7.00 USD

Pair of Vintage Style Metal Tin Cookie Cutters - Lion Rabbit
USA
Pair of Vintage Style Metal Tin...

$7.95 USD

Pair of Vintage Style Metal Tin...

$7.95 USD

Vintage Cookie King cookie press
USA
Vintage Cookie King cookie press

$9.99 USD

Vintage Cookie King cookie press

$9.99 USD

Vtg lot of 5 aluminum cookie cutters heart* star * horse * circle * and diamond
USA
Vtg lot of 5 aluminum cookie cutters...

$9.99 USD

Vtg lot of 5 aluminum cookie cutters...

$9.99 USD

4 Vintage CHRISTMAS COOKIE CUTTERS Santa Holly Leaf Reindeer Angel ALUMINUM
USA
4 Vintage CHRISTMAS COOKIE CUTTERS...

$12.97 USD

4 Vintage CHRISTMAS COOKIE CUTTERS...

$12.97 USD

Vintage Aluminum Mirro Cooky and Pastry Press Set
USA
Vintage Aluminum Mirro Cooky and...

$12.95 USD

Vintage Aluminum Mirro Cooky and...

$12.95 USD

Vintage Miniature Child
USA
Vintage Miniature Child's Pink...

$19.00 USD

Vintage Miniature Child's Pink...

$19.00 USD

Bath & Body Works SMART SOAP Automatic Dispenser + REFILL Touch Free SILVER
USA
Bath & Body Works SMART SOAP...

$79.99 USD

Bath & Body Works SMART SOAP...

$79.99 USD

VTG Lot 47 HRM Red Plastic Metal COOKIE Cutters XMAS Holiday Santa Tree NUMBERS
USA
VTG Lot 47 HRM Red Plastic Metal...

$79.99 USD

VTG Lot 47 HRM Red Plastic Metal...

$79.99 USD

Martha Stewart Basics By Mail Cake Decorating Set Rare Set
USA
Martha Stewart Basics By Mail Cake...

$59.47 USD

Martha Stewart Basics By Mail Cake...

$59.47 USD

Cookie Cutter Large Lot - HRM Red, Vintage, Metal, Hallmark, Jello & More - 95
USA
Cookie Cutter Large Lot - HRM Red,...

$15.99 USD

Cookie Cutter Large Lot - HRM Red,...

$15.99 USD

COOKIE CUTTER LOT 100 CHRISTMAS THANKSGIVING HOLIDAY METAL PLASTIC VINTAGE NOW
USA
COOKIE CUTTER LOT 100 CHRISTMAS...

$39.99 USD

COOKIE CUTTER LOT 100 CHRISTMAS...

$39.99 USD

13 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
13 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTERS

$39.99 USD

13 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTERS

$39.99 USD

Wear Ever Super Shooter Electric Cookie, Canape & Candy Maker No 70001 USA Mint
USA
Wear Ever Super Shooter Electric...

$39.99 USD

Wear Ever Super Shooter Electric...

$39.99 USD

Vintage 1976 Florida State Metal Soldered Cookie Cutter with Handle Signed
USA
Vintage 1976 Florida State Metal...

$39.99 USD

Vintage 1976 Florida State Metal...

$39.99 USD

2 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS - GEORGE WASHINGTON & ABE LINCOLN
USA
2 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS - GEORGE...

$39.99 USD

2 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS - GEORGE...

$39.99 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS+ ROSETTE AND TIMBALE IRON + DECORATOR SET+ COOKY PRESS
USA
VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS+ ROSETTE AND...

$35.00 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS+ ROSETTE AND...

$35.00 USD

Large Vintage Heavy Copper Cookie Cutters Zoo Animals Set Of Six
USA
Large Vintage Heavy Copper Cookie...

$28.00 USD

Large Vintage Heavy Copper Cookie...

$28.00 USD

Lot of 5 card suit Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters
USA
Lot of 5 card suit Vintage Metal...

$28.00 USD

Lot of 5 card suit Vintage Metal...

$28.00 USD

Mirror Cooky Pastry Kit Original Box Complete
USA
Mirror Cooky Pastry Kit Original Box...

$37.80 USD

Mirror Cooky Pastry Kit Original Box...

$37.80 USD

Vintage COOKIE CHEF TRIGGER QUICK Pastry Press Gun w Original Box Decorating
USA
Vintage COOKIE CHEF TRIGGER QUICK...

$49.21 USD

Vintage COOKIE CHEF TRIGGER QUICK...

$49.21 USD

Vintage Mirro All Season Cookie Cutters and Recipe Book
USA
Vintage Mirro All Season Cookie...

$25.00 USD

Vintage Mirro All Season Cookie...

$25.00 USD

Vintage Red Plastic CHRISTMAS Cookie Cutters in Original Box & Nativity Bake Set
USA
Vintage Red Plastic CHRISTMAS Cookie...

$25.00 USD

Vintage Red Plastic CHRISTMAS Cookie...

$25.00 USD

Set of 4 card suit Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters
USA
Set of 4 card suit Vintage Metal...

$25.00 USD

Set of 4 card suit Vintage Metal...

$25.00 USD

Vintage Farmhouse Gathering Red White Christmas Cookie Cutter Lot Tin Timer
USA
Vintage Farmhouse Gathering Red White...

$49.95 USD

Vintage Farmhouse Gathering Red White...

$49.95 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG THISTLE HEART BROWN SHORTBREAD COOKIE MOLD
USA
HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG THISTLE...

$49.95 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY LARGE VTG THISTLE...

$49.95 USD

VINTAGE WEAR-EVE SUPER SHOOTER ELECTRIC COOKIE CANAPE
USA
VINTAGE WEAR-EVE SUPER SHOOTER...

$22.00 USD

VINTAGE WEAR-EVE SUPER SHOOTER...

$22.00 USD

HUGE LOT 460 Vintage Metal COOKIE CUTTERS - From a Collector- Never Used
USA
HUGE LOT 460 Vintage Metal COOKIE...

$175.00 USD

HUGE LOT 460 Vintage Metal COOKIE...

$175.00 USD

WEAR-EVER SUPER SHOOTER ELECTRIC COOKIE CANAPE & CANDY MAKER 70001
USA
WEAR-EVER SUPER SHOOTER ELECTRIC...

$59.99 USD

WEAR-EVER SUPER SHOOTER ELECTRIC...

$59.99 USD

4 Vintage RARE COOKIE CUTTER, ORIGINAL
USA
4 Vintage RARE COOKIE CUTTER, ORIGINAL

$74.00 USD

4 Vintage RARE COOKIE CUTTER, ORIGINAL

$74.00 USD

Vintage Kitchen Cookie Cutters Zinc Green Handle Gingerbread Geometric Shapes
USA
Vintage Kitchen Cookie Cutters Zinc...

$54.99 USD

Vintage Kitchen Cookie Cutters Zinc...

$54.99 USD

Lot Of 67 Vintage Plastic And Metal Cookie Cutters
USA
Lot Of 67 Vintage Plastic And Metal...

$65.00 USD

Lot Of 67 Vintage Plastic And Metal...

$65.00 USD

Martha By Mail RARE Copper Cookie Pastry Cutter Set, Teacup & Cake Wedding, MIB
USA
Martha By Mail RARE Copper Cookie...

$145.00 USD

Martha By Mail RARE Copper Cookie...

$145.00 USD

Vintage 54 Piece Christmas Cookie Cutters Now 15% Off
USA
Vintage 54 Piece Christmas Cookie...

$59.50 USD

Vintage 54 Piece Christmas Cookie...

$59.50 USD

50 Cookie Cutters HRM Hallmark Wilton Metal Plastic Holiday Halloween Christmas
USA
50 Cookie Cutters HRM Hallmark Wilton...

$40.76 USD

50 Cookie Cutters HRM Hallmark Wilton...

$40.76 USD

Vintage 1978 Chilton 12 Twelve Days of Christmas COOKIE CUTTER SET Kraft Plastic
USA
Vintage 1978 Chilton 12 Twelve Days...

$22.99 USD

Vintage 1978 Chilton 12 Twelve Days...

$22.99 USD

Antique Rare Tin Metal Standing Bear Soldered Cookie Cutter 6" Tall
USA
Antique Rare Tin Metal Standing Bear...

$44.99 USD

Antique Rare Tin Metal Standing Bear...

$44.99 USD

Vtg Wear Ever 1977 Super Shooter Electric Cookie Press Canape Candy Maker 70001
USA
Vtg Wear Ever 1977 Super Shooter...

$36.99 USD

Vtg Wear Ever 1977 Super Shooter...

$36.99 USD

Mirror Cookie Press Kit & Assorted Metal / Aluminum Cookie Cutters Vtg. S9206
USA
Mirror Cookie Press Kit & Assorted...

$49.99 USD

Mirror Cookie Press Kit & Assorted...

$49.99 USD

Antique Rolling Donut Cutter
USA
Antique Rolling Donut Cutter

$69.99 USD

Antique Rolling Donut Cutter

$69.99 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS MOLDS STAMPS Lot of 164
USA
VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS MOLDS STAMPS...

$50.00 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS MOLDS STAMPS...

$50.00 USD

Vintage Ceramic Cookie Jar Mushroom
USA
Vintage Ceramic Cookie Jar Mushroom

$11.99 USD

Vintage Ceramic Cookie Jar Mushroom

$11.99 USD

Vintage Stainless Steel Biscuit Maker / Cookie Press w/ 19 Discs by Shule
USA
Vintage Stainless Steel Biscuit Maker...

$23.00 USD

Vintage Stainless Steel Biscuit Maker...

$23.00 USD

17 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters
USA
17 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters

$23.00 USD

17 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters

$23.00 USD

Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters - HRM Wilton ++
USA
Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie...

$24.99 USD

Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie...

$24.99 USD

Estate Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters Aluminum Wilton Plastic Halloween Christmas
USA
Estate Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters...

$24.99 USD

Estate Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters...

$24.99 USD

Mirro Brand ~ 358-AM Cooky-Pastry Press ~ Vtg Culinary ~ Lady Fingers_Eclairs_+
USA
Mirro Brand ~ 358-AM Cooky-Pastry...

$24.99 USD

Mirro Brand ~ 358-AM Cooky-Pastry...

$24.99 USD

Lot of 24 Figural Miniature Little Metal Cookie Cutters
USA
Lot of 24 Figural Miniature Little...

$24.99 USD

Lot of 24 Figural Miniature Little...

$24.99 USD

Antique ca. 1910 Cookie Cutters in The Original Tin, 10 Crinkled Edged Cutter
USA
Antique ca. 1910 Cookie Cutters in...

$24.89 USD

Antique ca. 1910 Cookie Cutters in...

$24.89 USD

5 Antique Primitive Handmade Tin Cookie Cutters Bottle shaped ???
USA
5 Antique Primitive Handmade Tin ...

$44.44 USD

5 Antique Primitive Handmade Tin ...

$44.44 USD

Vintage Wood Butter Cookie Mold Double Design Woman and Man
USA
Vintage Wood Butter Cookie Mold...

$30.00 USD

Vintage Wood Butter Cookie Mold...

$30.00 USD

VTG Brown Bag Cookie Art Mold GABRIEL ANGEL 95 & Angel With Heart 87 Hill Design
USA
VTG Brown Bag Cookie Art Mold GABRIEL...

$39.00 USD

VTG Brown Bag Cookie Art Mold GABRIEL...

$39.00 USD

Vintage 1950
USA
Vintage 1950's Wear-Ever Salad Maker...

$39.00 USD

Vintage 1950's Wear-Ever Salad Maker...

$39.00 USD

Vintage Lot of 64 Cookie Cutters Thanksgiving Christmas Hutzler Hallmark Wilton
USA
Vintage Lot of 64 Cookie Cutters ...

$31.99 USD

Vintage Lot of 64 Cookie Cutters ...

$31.99 USD

VINTAGE METAL COOKIE PRESS
USA
VINTAGE METAL COOKIE PRESS

$37.50 USD

VINTAGE METAL COOKIE PRESS

$37.50 USD

Vintage wood cookie or butter mold press hand carved European pair
USA
Vintage wood cookie or butter mold...

$32.00 USD

Vintage wood cookie or butter mold...

$32.00 USD

5 piece Tin COOKIE CUTTER MOLD Group Chicken * Santa * Chick * Rabbit VINTAGE
USA
5 piece Tin COOKIE CUTTER MOLD Group...

$8.50 USD

5 piece Tin COOKIE CUTTER MOLD Group...

$8.50 USD

Antique Wooden Roller German Cookie Press Germany
USA
Antique Wooden Roller German Cookie...

$8.50 USD

Antique Wooden Roller German Cookie...

$8.50 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER LOT~METAL/PLASTIC~LARGE FLAT RATE BOX~3 LBS~MIXED
USA
VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER...

$19.99 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER...

$19.99 USD

6 VINTAGE CHRISTMAS COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
6 VINTAGE CHRISTMAS COOKIE CUTTERS

$19.99 USD

6 VINTAGE CHRISTMAS COOKIE CUTTERS

$19.99 USD

Vintage Hoan 6 Sided Metal Cookie Cutter Heart Diamond Cross Spade Star Club
USA
Vintage Hoan 6 Sided Metal Cookie...

$19.99 USD

Vintage Hoan 6 Sided Metal Cookie...

$19.99 USD

5 VINTAGE METAL COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
5 VINTAGE METAL COOKIE CUTTERS

$19.99 USD

5 VINTAGE METAL COOKIE CUTTERS

$19.99 USD

Wilton--stretchy cutters in box still taped shut
USA
Wilton--stretchy cutters in box still...

$45.70 USD

Wilton--stretchy cutters in box still...

$45.70 USD

5 LARGE SOLID COPPER COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
5 LARGE SOLID COPPER COOKIE CUTTERS

$60.00 USD

5 LARGE SOLID COPPER COOKIE CUTTERS

$60.00 USD

Vintage 1950
USA
Vintage 1950's Mid century Cookie...

$37.77 USD

Vintage 1950's Mid century Cookie...

$37.77 USD

Scarce Set of Interlocking Antique Heart Tin Cookie Cutters, Kitchenware, Baking
USA
Scarce Set of Interlocking Antique...

$32.50 USD

Scarce Set of Interlocking Antique...

$32.50 USD

(13) Vintage Cookie Cutters, Red Handle, Gingerbread Man, Etc
USA
(13) Vintage Cookie Cutters, Red...

$40.00 USD

(13) Vintage Cookie Cutters, Red...

$40.00 USD

Estate Lot 25pc Antique Cake/Cookie Cutters Cats, Bird, Shapes, Etc.
USA
Estate Lot 25pc Antique Cake/Cookie...

$40.00 USD

Estate Lot 25pc Antique Cake/Cookie...

$40.00 USD

Mid Century Wear Ever Aluminum Cooky Press Cookie Press in Box
USA
Mid Century Wear Ever Aluminum Cooky...

$40.00 USD

Mid Century Wear Ever Aluminum Cooky...

$40.00 USD

Vintage Playing Card cutters
USA
Vintage Playing Card cutters

$40.00 USD

Vintage Playing Card cutters

$40.00 USD

Tupperware Cookie Cutters Vintage Set
USA
Tupperware Cookie Cutters Vintage Set

$24.95 USD

Tupperware Cookie Cutters Vintage Set

$24.95 USD

(2) Large Copper Handmade Cookie Cutters Boy & Girl 10"
USA
(2) Large Copper Handmade Cookie...

$29.00 USD

(2) Large Copper Handmade Cookie...

$29.00 USD

Antique Standing Female Figure Tin Cookie Cutter
USA
Antique Standing Female Figure Tin...

$36.00 USD

Antique Standing Female Figure Tin...

$36.00 USD

Metal Cookie Cutter Sets Box Lot
USA
Metal Cookie Cutter Sets Box Lot

$17.49 USD

Metal Cookie Cutter Sets Box Lot

$17.49 USD

Mirror Cookie Press Kit & Assorted Metal / Aluminum Cookie Cutters Vtg. (S9016)
USA
Mirror Cookie Press Kit & Assorted...

$45.99 USD

Mirror Cookie Press Kit & Assorted...

$45.99 USD

Hallmark Peanuts Christmas Cookie Cutters - Charlie Brown, Lucy, Snoopy, Linus
USA
Hallmark Peanuts Christmas Cookie...

$24.00 USD

Hallmark Peanuts Christmas Cookie...

$24.00 USD

vintage SPRINGERLE COOKIE Butter Roller MOLD folk art pattern Fruit Bird 14.5"
USA
vintage SPRINGERLE COOKIE Butter...

$64.95 USD

vintage SPRINGERLE COOKIE Butter...

$64.95 USD

Cookie Press Fall Terracott Scarecrow Pumpkin Witch Ghost Halloween Thanksgiving
USA
Cookie Press Fall Terracott Scarecrow...

$29.99 USD

Cookie Press Fall Terracott Scarecrow...

$29.99 USD

VINTAGE ALUMINUM MIRRO COOKY & PASTRY PRESS 11 disc IN BOX EUC 3 tips 358-AM
USA
VINTAGE ALUMINUM MIRRO COOKY & PASTRY...

$34.99 USD

VINTAGE ALUMINUM MIRRO COOKY & PASTRY...

$34.99 USD

Baking, Pastry Lot: Cookie Cutters, Silicone Molds, Cake Decoration Tips
USA
Baking, Pastry Lot: Cookie Cutters,...

$16.88 USD

Baking, Pastry Lot: Cookie Cutters,...

$16.88 USD

Large Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters - 25 Cookie Cutters
USA
Large Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters -...

$21.95 USD

Large Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters -...

$21.95 USD

Vintage Mirro Cooky Pastry Press 358-AM
USA
Vintage Mirro Cooky Pastry Press 358-AM

$54.95 USD

Vintage Mirro Cooky Pastry Press 358-AM

$54.95 USD

Lot Of 20 Vintage Cookie Cutters Tupperware Pre-Owned Good Condition
USA
Lot Of 20 Vintage Cookie Cutters...

$32.49 USD

Lot Of 20 Vintage Cookie Cutters...

$32.49 USD

TUPPERWARE NEW VINTAGE 5 pc House/Family COOKIE CUTTERS #2558
USA
TUPPERWARE NEW VINTAGE 5 pc...

$34.20 USD

TUPPERWARE NEW VINTAGE 5 pc...

$34.20 USD

Vintage Mirro 16 pc. Cookie Pastry Press
USA
Vintage Mirro 16 pc. Cookie Pastry Press

$23.50 USD

Vintage Mirro 16 pc. Cookie Pastry Press

$23.50 USD

9 HRM CROWN MIX LOT COOKIE CUTTERS CHRISTMAS THANKSGIVING EASTER
USA
9 HRM CROWN MIX LOT COOKIE CUTTERS...

$15.00 USD

9 HRM CROWN MIX LOT COOKIE CUTTERS...

$15.00 USD

Primitive Handmade Gingerbread Man Folk Art Cookie Cutters 9” Copper & Wood
USA
Primitive Handmade Gingerbread Man...

$10.00 USD

Primitive Handmade Gingerbread Man...

$10.00 USD

VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE INDUSTRIAL COMMERCIAL BAKERY Qty 6
USA
VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE...

$239.99 USD

VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE...

$239.99 USD

Vintage Lot 65 Plastic & Metal Holiday Animals Cookie Cutters Crafts Play doh
USA
Vintage Lot 65 Plastic & Metal...

$32.26 USD

Vintage Lot 65 Plastic & Metal...

$32.26 USD

kitchen collectibles copper cookie or dough cutters
USA
kitchen collectibles copper cookie or...

$19.95 USD

kitchen collectibles copper cookie or...

$19.95 USD

Vintage Old Fashioned Cookie Cutters 12 Designs in Original Box Metal Cutters
USA
Vintage Old Fashioned Cookie Cutters...

$16.95 USD

Vintage Old Fashioned Cookie Cutters...

$16.95 USD

Peanuts Christmas Cookie Cutters Hallmark - Charlie Brown, Snoopy, Linus, Lucy
USA
Peanuts Christmas Cookie Cutters...

$23.90 USD

Peanuts Christmas Cookie Cutters...

$23.90 USD

Mirro Aluminum Kitchen Cookie Press Maker Cutter Vintage
USA
Mirro Aluminum Kitchen Cookie Press...

$19.05 USD

Mirro Aluminum Kitchen Cookie Press...

$19.05 USD

Primitive Tin Cookie Cutter Hand Made Heart Design Large
USA
Primitive Tin Cookie Cutter Hand Made...

$45.00 USD

Primitive Tin Cookie Cutter Hand Made...

$45.00 USD

VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD INDUSTRIAL COMMERCIAL BAKERY PLAYBOY BUNNY RABBIT EASTER
USA
VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD INDUSTRIAL...

$49.50 USD

VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD INDUSTRIAL...

$49.50 USD