Shop by Department
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor

Other Vintage Cookie Cutters | Surplus Network

Vintage Red Plastic Fortress Christmas Cookie Cutters NOS 12 Pc Manger Scene
USA
Vintage Red Plastic Fortress...

$34.99 USD

Vintage Red Plastic Fortress...

$34.99 USD

Vintage MIRRO Pastry & COOKIE PRESS 358-AM Cooky 12 Discs 3 Tips Recipe Booklet
USA
Vintage MIRRO Pastry & COOKIE PRESS...

$34.99 USD

Vintage MIRRO Pastry & COOKIE PRESS...

$34.99 USD

5 LARGE SOLID COPPER COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
5 LARGE SOLID COPPER COOKIE CUTTERS

$60.00 USD

5 LARGE SOLID COPPER COOKIE CUTTERS

$60.00 USD

Lot Of 67 Vintage Plastic And Metal Cookie Cutters
USA
Lot Of 67 Vintage Plastic And Metal...

$60.00 USD

Lot Of 67 Vintage Plastic And Metal...

$60.00 USD

VTG WESTCO INDUSTRIAL TIN WWII AIRPLANE COOKIE CUTTER PRIMITIVE SPRING & WOOD
USA
VTG WESTCO INDUSTRIAL TIN WWII...

$60.00 USD

VTG WESTCO INDUSTRIAL TIN WWII...

$60.00 USD

Vintage COOKY CUTTERS – 11 cutters copper – original mounting – NEW!
USA
Vintage COOKY CUTTERS – 11 cutters...

$40.00 USD

Vintage COOKY CUTTERS – 11 cutters...

$40.00 USD

LARGE Metal Cookie Cutter Assortment Set of Six (6)
USA
LARGE Metal Cookie Cutter Assortment...

$14.95 USD

LARGE Metal Cookie Cutter Assortment...

$14.95 USD

Cookie Press Fall Terracott Scarecrow Pumpkin Witch Ghost Halloween Thanksgiving
USA
Cookie Press Fall Terracott Scarecrow...

$29.99 USD

Cookie Press Fall Terracott Scarecrow...

$29.99 USD

Vintage HUGE LOT of 25 Cookie Cutters - L@@K!!!
USA
Vintage HUGE LOT of 25 Cookie Cutters...

$29.99 USD

Vintage HUGE LOT of 25 Cookie Cutters...

$29.99 USD

WearEver Super Shooter Electric Cookie Candy Maker 70001 & accessory kit
USA
WearEver Super Shooter Electric...

$29.99 USD

WearEver Super Shooter Electric...

$29.99 USD

Vintage Wear-Ever Super Shooter 70123 The Electric Food Gun Cookie Press EUC
USA
Vintage Wear-Ever Super Shooter 70123...

$29.99 USD

Vintage Wear-Ever Super Shooter 70123...

$29.99 USD

Wear-Ever Super Shooter #70001 Electric Cookie Canape & Candy Maker EUC
USA
Wear-Ever Super Shooter #70001...

$29.99 USD

Wear-Ever Super Shooter #70001...

$29.99 USD

Cookie Cutters Thanksgiving Christmas Letters Animals Construction Equipment NIP
USA
Cookie Cutters Thanksgiving Christmas...

$29.99 USD

Cookie Cutters Thanksgiving Christmas...

$29.99 USD

Wear-Ever Super Shooter 1-No.70001 Electric Cookie Press Canape & Candy Maker
USA
Wear-Ever Super Shooter 1-No.70001...

$29.99 USD

Wear-Ever Super Shooter 1-No.70001...

$29.99 USD

ANTIQUE PRIMITIVE HAND CARVED WOOD ANGEL SHAPE COOKIE MOLD RARE WEST GERMANY
USA
ANTIQUE PRIMITIVE HAND CARVED WOOD...

$39.95 USD

ANTIQUE PRIMITIVE HAND CARVED WOOD...

$39.95 USD

Vintage Kalkus-Hirco Christmas Rosette Iron Set
USA
Vintage Kalkus-Hirco Christmas...

$49.99 USD

Vintage Kalkus-Hirco Christmas...

$49.99 USD

Kitchen Junk Drawer 70+ pieces Few Old Few New Lots of Goodies
USA
Kitchen Junk Drawer 70+ pieces Few...

$49.99 USD

Kitchen Junk Drawer 70+ pieces Few...

$49.99 USD

Halloween Vintage 6 Large Cookie Cutters Ghost Cat Witch Bat Pumpkin
USA
Halloween Vintage 6 Large Cookie...

$49.99 USD

Halloween Vintage 6 Large Cookie...

$49.99 USD

Vintage 1976 Florida State Metal Soldered Cookie Cutter with Handle Signed
USA
Vintage 1976 Florida State Metal...

$39.99 USD

Vintage 1976 Florida State Metal...

$39.99 USD

13 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
13 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTERS

$39.99 USD

13 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTERS

$39.99 USD

39 Vtg Metal Cookie Cutters. Hearts,Animals,etc.
USA
39 Vtg Metal Cookie Cutters....

$39.99 USD

39 Vtg Metal Cookie Cutters....

$39.99 USD

2 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS - GEORGE WASHINGTON & ABE LINCOLN
USA
2 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS - GEORGE...

$39.99 USD

2 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS - GEORGE...

$39.99 USD

Vintage Mirro Cooky Press 0358 Box 11 Plates 3 Tips & Recipe Book
USA
Vintage Mirro Cooky Press 0358 Box 11...

$39.99 USD

Vintage Mirro Cooky Press 0358 Box 11...

$39.99 USD

Vintage 54 Piece Christmas Cookie Cutters
USA
Vintage 54 Piece Christmas Cookie...

$70.00 USD

Vintage 54 Piece Christmas Cookie...

$70.00 USD

LARGE LOT COOKIE CUTTERS SOME VINTAGE
USA
LARGE LOT COOKIE CUTTERS SOME VINTAGE

$28.00 USD

LARGE LOT COOKIE CUTTERS SOME VINTAGE

$28.00 USD

Antique Standing Female Figure Tin Cookie Cutter
USA
Antique Standing Female Figure Tin...

$36.00 USD

Antique Standing Female Figure Tin...

$36.00 USD

Vintage Wear-Ever Super Shooter Electric Cookie, Canape & Candy Maker NEW
USA
Vintage Wear-Ever Super Shooter...

$49.50 USD

Vintage Wear-Ever Super Shooter...

$49.50 USD

WEAR-EVER SUPER SHOOTER ELECTRIC COOKIE CANAPE & CANDY MAKER 70001
USA
WEAR-EVER SUPER SHOOTER ELECTRIC...

$59.99 USD

WEAR-EVER SUPER SHOOTER ELECTRIC...

$59.99 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS MOLDS STAMPS Lot of 164
USA
VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS MOLDS STAMPS...

$50.00 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS MOLDS STAMPS...

$50.00 USD

Antique Primitive Sifter Cake Server Clubs Cookie Cutter Spoons Windchime ❤️m17
USA
Antique Primitive Sifter Cake Server...

$50.00 USD

Antique Primitive Sifter Cake Server...

$50.00 USD

Vintage Mirro Cooky-Pastry Press 358-AM (Complete Set)
USA
Vintage Mirro Cooky-Pastry Press...

$38.00 USD

Vintage Mirro Cooky-Pastry Press...

$38.00 USD

VTG Brown Bag Cookie Art Mold GABRIEL ANGEL 95 & Angel With Heart 87 Hill Design
USA
VTG Brown Bag Cookie Art Mold GABRIEL...

$39.00 USD

VTG Brown Bag Cookie Art Mold GABRIEL...

$39.00 USD

Wearever super shooter model 70123
USA
Wearever super shooter model 70123

$39.00 USD

Wearever super shooter model 70123

$39.00 USD

Vintage Hanukkah Cookie Collection & Cookie Cutters Kids Cooking Kits Sealed
USA
Vintage Hanukkah Cookie Collection &...

$29.95 USD

Vintage Hanukkah Cookie Collection &...

$29.95 USD

Vintage Aluminum Cake Cutters & Cake decorating kits in orignal boxes!
USA
Vintage Aluminum Cake Cutters & Cake...

$29.95 USD

Vintage Aluminum Cake Cutters & Cake...

$29.95 USD

NORDIC WARE TRADITIONAL ROSETTE & TIMBALE COOKIE SET 7 PEICE
USA
NORDIC WARE TRADITIONAL ROSETTE &...

$21.75 USD

NORDIC WARE TRADITIONAL ROSETTE &...

$21.75 USD

VINTAGE MIRRO COOKY CUTTERS POPULAR DESIGNS RUSTPROOF IN BOX RECIPES ON BACK
USA
VINTAGE MIRRO COOKY CUTTERS POPULAR...

$19.99 USD

VINTAGE MIRRO COOKY CUTTERS POPULAR...

$19.99 USD

WearEver SUPER SHOOTER Electric Cookie Press Nice Wear Ever Cutter
USA
WearEver SUPER SHOOTER Electric...

$19.99 USD

WearEver SUPER SHOOTER Electric...

$19.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY Large Brown Hearts Design Shortbread Cookie mold
USA
HARTSTONE POTTERY Large Brown Hearts...

$19.99 USD

HARTSTONE POTTERY Large Brown Hearts...

$19.99 USD

Antique Round Tin Cookie Cutters Crimped Scallop Fluted Edge 8 Graduated Sizes
USA
Antique Round Tin Cookie Cutters...

$19.99 USD

Antique Round Tin Cookie Cutters...

$19.99 USD

Vintage Peanuts Cookie Cutter Keepsake Box Charlie Brown Snoopy Charles Schultz
USA
Vintage Peanuts Cookie Cutter...

$19.99 USD

Vintage Peanuts Cookie Cutter...

$19.99 USD

Vintage Rolling Cookie Cutter Decoupeur Roulant De Petits Fours With 18 Cutters
USA
Vintage Rolling Cookie Cutter...

$19.99 USD

Vintage Rolling Cookie Cutter...

$19.99 USD

Vintage Collection Of Cookie Cutters
USA
Vintage Collection Of Cookie Cutters

$19.99 USD

Vintage Collection Of Cookie Cutters

$19.99 USD

10 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS AND MOLDS
USA
10 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS AND MOLDS

$19.99 USD

10 VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTERS AND MOLDS

$19.99 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER LOT~METAL/PLASTIC~LARGE FLAT RATE BOX~3 LBS~MIXED
USA
VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER...

$19.99 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER...

$19.99 USD

COOKIE CUTTERS Huge Lot of 157 Great for Baking Crafts Clay Holidays Events C
USA
COOKIE CUTTERS Huge Lot of 157 Great...

$19.99 USD

COOKIE CUTTERS Huge Lot of 157 Great...

$19.99 USD

WOW BNIB STILL SEALED WEAR EVER SUPER SHOOTER COOKIE PRESS
USA
WOW BNIB STILL SEALED WEAR EVER SUPER...

$150.00 USD

WOW BNIB STILL SEALED WEAR EVER SUPER...

$150.00 USD

VINTAGE KITCHEN COLLECTABLES OMAHA SOLID COPPER RARE COOKIE CUTTER LOT
USA
VINTAGE KITCHEN COLLECTABLES OMAHA ...

$150.00 USD

VINTAGE KITCHEN COLLECTABLES OMAHA ...

$150.00 USD

WOW NEW STILL SEALED WEAR EVER SUPER SHOOTER COOKIE PRESS
USA
WOW NEW STILL SEALED WEAR EVER SUPER...

$129.95 USD

WOW NEW STILL SEALED WEAR EVER SUPER...

$129.95 USD

4 VINTAGE METAL CRIMPED COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
4 VINTAGE METAL CRIMPED COOKIE...

$24.99 USD

4 VINTAGE METAL CRIMPED COOKIE...

$24.99 USD

All Metal Cookie Cutters, 13 pieces Various Shapes & Sizes
USA
All Metal Cookie Cutters, 13 pieces...

$24.99 USD

All Metal Cookie Cutters, 13 pieces...

$24.99 USD

Vintage SCOTTIE DOG Cookie Cutters - Aluminum Metal & HRM Red Plastic - Lot Of 5
USA
Vintage SCOTTIE DOG Cookie Cutters -...

$24.99 USD

Vintage SCOTTIE DOG Cookie Cutters -...

$24.99 USD

COOKIE CUTTERS-- Lot 105 pcs--Aluminum/Tin/Red/Copper/Plastic--Vintage
USA
COOKIE CUTTERS-- Lot 105...

$24.99 USD

COOKIE CUTTERS-- Lot 105...

$24.99 USD

Lot of 24 Figural Miniature Little Metal Cookie Cutters
USA
Lot of 24 Figural Miniature Little...

$24.99 USD

Lot of 24 Figural Miniature Little...

$24.99 USD

Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie Cutters - HRM Wilton ++
USA
Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie...

$24.99 USD

Huge Assorted Lot of Vintage Cookie...

$24.99 USD

Lot of 17 Vintage HRM Tupperware Metal Halloween Christmas Cookie Cutters
USA
Lot of 17 Vintage HRM Tupperware...

$19.98 USD

Lot of 17 Vintage HRM Tupperware...

$19.98 USD

Vintage Cookie Cutter Lot
USA
Vintage Cookie Cutter Lot

$25.00 USD

Vintage Cookie Cutter Lot

$25.00 USD

Ex Rare Antique 6 Animal Pennsylvania Cookie Cutter Ball Mold 19th Century 1869?
USA
Ex Rare Antique 6 Animal Pennsylvania...

$159.95 USD

Ex Rare Antique 6 Animal Pennsylvania...

$159.95 USD

34 COOKIE CUTTERS PLASTIC COPPER ALUMINUM CHRISTMAS HALLOWEEN VARIETY
USA
34 COOKIE CUTTERS PLASTIC COPPER...

$34.95 USD

34 COOKIE CUTTERS PLASTIC COPPER...

$34.95 USD

Vintage Lot 65 Plastic & Metal Holiday Animals Cookie Cutters Crafts Play doh
USA
Vintage Lot 65 Plastic & Metal...

$34.95 USD

Vintage Lot 65 Plastic & Metal...

$34.95 USD

Vintage Lot 20 Plastic & Metal Cookie Cutters HRM Holiday Animals Crafts
USA
Vintage Lot 20 Plastic & Metal Cookie...

$34.95 USD

Vintage Lot 20 Plastic & Metal Cookie...

$34.95 USD

Lot of 21 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters of all sizes and shapes, mostly animals
USA
Lot of 21 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters...

$49.00 USD

Lot of 21 Vintage Tin Cookie Cutters...

$49.00 USD

4 Vintage RARE COOKIE CUTTER, ORIGINAL
USA
4 Vintage RARE COOKIE CUTTER, ORIGINAL

$49.00 USD

4 Vintage RARE COOKIE CUTTER, ORIGINAL

$49.00 USD

3 Clay Cookie Molds Santa Claus Goose & Rooster Brown Bag Cookie Art & Hartstone
USA
3 Clay Cookie Molds Santa Claus Goose...

$30.14 USD

3 Clay Cookie Molds Santa Claus Goose...

$30.14 USD

LARGE VINTAGE LOT OVER 50 COOKIE CUTTERS
USA
LARGE VINTAGE LOT OVER 50 COOKIE CUTTERS

$21.99 USD

LARGE VINTAGE LOT OVER 50 COOKIE CUTTERS

$21.99 USD

Vintage Mirro cookie press in original box
USA
Vintage Mirro cookie press in...

$20.00 USD

Vintage Mirro cookie press in...

$20.00 USD

VINTAGE BROWN BAG COOKIE ART MOLD WITH RECIPE BOOK
USA
VINTAGE BROWN BAG COOKIE ART MOLD...

$20.00 USD

VINTAGE BROWN BAG COOKIE ART MOLD...

$20.00 USD

Vintage Christmas Cookie Cutters Red Clear Plastic HRM LOT 15 Santa Holiday Tree
USA
Vintage Christmas Cookie Cutters Red...

$35.00 USD

Vintage Christmas Cookie Cutters Red...

$35.00 USD

Mirro Cookie Pastry Press with Box & Instruction Recipe Booklet Model 358-AM
USA
Mirro Cookie Pastry Press with Box &...

$35.00 USD

Mirro Cookie Pastry Press with Box &...

$35.00 USD

LOT OF 19 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN METAL COOKIE CUTTERS GREAT SHAPES 6 IN BOXED SET
USA
LOT OF 19 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN METAL...

$35.00 USD

LOT OF 19 VINTAGE HALLOWEEN METAL...

$35.00 USD

Christmas Gingerbread man Metal Cookie Cutter Decor, 30" Seasonal
USA
Christmas Gingerbread man Metal...

$159.99 USD

Christmas Gingerbread man Metal...

$159.99 USD

Antique Round Tin 15 lb & Antique/Vintage Cookie Cutters Lancaster Pa PRIMITIVE
USA
Antique Round Tin 15 lb &...

$125.00 USD

Antique Round Tin 15 lb &...

$125.00 USD

VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE INDUSTRIAL COMMERCIAL BAKERY Qty 6
USA
VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE...

$239.99 USD

VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE...

$239.99 USD

Lot Of 16 Mixed Vintage Cookie Cutters Christmas Animals President Rose Designs
USA
Lot Of 16 Mixed Vintage Cookie...

$32.00 USD

Lot Of 16 Mixed Vintage Cookie...

$32.00 USD

Giant Vintage Metal Primitive Gingerbread Man Hand Made Cookie Baking Kitchen
USA
Giant Vintage Metal Primitive...

$32.00 USD

Giant Vintage Metal Primitive...

$32.00 USD

Vintage Primitive Folk Art Cookie Butter Mold Man Riding Wild Pig Wall Decor
USA
Vintage Primitive Folk Art Cookie...

$69.97 USD

Vintage Primitive Folk Art Cookie...

$69.97 USD

VINTAGE METAL COOKIE PRESS
USA
VINTAGE METAL COOKIE PRESS

$37.50 USD

VINTAGE METAL COOKIE PRESS

$37.50 USD

Vintage Mirro Aluminum Holiday Cooky & Pastry Press 358-AM Box & Recipe Manual
USA
Vintage Mirro Aluminum Holiday Cooky...

$27.31 USD

Vintage Mirro Aluminum Holiday Cooky...

$27.31 USD

Acacia Serving Trinket Bowl with Lid 8" x 3" Handcrafted From One Piece of Wood
USA
Acacia Serving Trinket Bowl with Lid...

$37.99 USD

Acacia Serving Trinket Bowl with Lid...

$37.99 USD

Vtg Cookie Board Gingerbread Man Shape Gourmet Gifts Set Expired NOS TV prop
USA
Vtg Cookie Board Gingerbread Man...

$29.55 USD

Vtg Cookie Board Gingerbread Man...

$29.55 USD

Vtg Cookie Cutters (5) 2 copper,3 aluminum Christmas Trees & Reindeer & a Angel
USA
Vtg Cookie Cutters (5) 2 copper,3...

$118.00 USD

Vtg Cookie Cutters (5) 2 copper,3...

$118.00 USD

Vtg- WEAR EVER SUPER SHOOTER Electric Cookie Press Canape Candy Maker 70001-1976
USA
Vtg- WEAR EVER SUPER SHOOTER Electric...

$89.99 USD

Vtg- WEAR EVER SUPER SHOOTER Electric...

$89.99 USD

Vintage Mason
USA
Vintage Mason's Patent 1858 Jar...

$95.00 USD

Vintage Mason's Patent 1858 Jar...

$95.00 USD

20 Vintage Christmas Cookie Cutters ~ Aluminum and Plastic~Mirro Tupperware More
USA
20 Vintage Christmas Cookie Cutters ~...

$35.99 USD

20 Vintage Christmas Cookie Cutters ~...

$35.99 USD

Vintage Chilton Twelve Days of Christmas Plastic Cookie Cutter Set 12
USA
Vintage Chilton Twelve Days of...

$21.95 USD

Vintage Chilton Twelve Days of...

$21.95 USD

Vtg Durkee Spice French
USA
Vtg Durkee Spice French's Cookie...

$22.50 USD

Vtg Durkee Spice French's Cookie...

$22.50 USD

SNOOPY CAKE TOWN PLASTIC COOKIE CUTTER SET IN CASE Japan Advertising New
USA
SNOOPY CAKE TOWN PLASTIC COOKIE...

$46.74 USD

SNOOPY CAKE TOWN PLASTIC COOKIE...

$46.74 USD

MIXED LOT OF 137 VINTAGE METAL COPPER AND PLASTIC COOKIE CUTTERS WILTON & MORE
USA
MIXED LOT OF 137 VINTAGE METAL COPPER...

$99.95 USD

MIXED LOT OF 137 VINTAGE METAL COPPER...

$99.95 USD

Mirro Vintage Cookie Pastry Screw Press And Icing Dispenser Cake Decorating Set
USA
Mirro Vintage Cookie Pastry Screw...

$23.99 USD

Mirro Vintage Cookie Pastry Screw...

$23.99 USD

Mirro Cooky & Pastry Press #358 aluminum 9 Heavy Shape Forms 3 Tips Vtg
USA
Mirro Cooky & Pastry Press #358...

$15.99 USD

Mirro Cooky & Pastry Press #358...

$15.99 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER LOT RETRO COLLECTABLE PLASTIC WITCH CAT BABY BED
USA
VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER LOT RETRO...

$33.00 USD

VINTAGE COOKIE CUTTER LOT RETRO...

$33.00 USD

VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE INDUSTRIAL COMMERCIAL BAKERY WITCH ON BROOM
USA
VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE...

$42.00 USD

VTG COOKIE CUTTER MOLD HAND MADE...

$42.00 USD

Mirro Aluminum Kitchen Cookie Press Maker Cutter Vintage
USA
Mirro Aluminum Kitchen Cookie Press...

$16.19 USD

Mirro Aluminum Kitchen Cookie Press...

$16.19 USD

Wear Ever Super Shooter Electric FoodGun WITH BOX
USA
Wear Ever Super Shooter Electric...

$29.90 USD

Wear Ever Super Shooter Electric...

$29.90 USD

7 1/2" T Yellow Splatter Speckled Ceramic Vase Planter Pot 7 1/2" Mouth D
USA
7 1/2" T Yellow Splatter Speckled...

$19.95 USD

7 1/2" T Yellow Splatter Speckled...

$19.95 USD

COOKIE CRAFT MOLD BROWN BAG COOKIE ART 1996 Hanukkah Cut Apart Hill Designs Vtg
USA
COOKIE CRAFT MOLD BROWN BAG COOKIE...

$15.00 USD

COOKIE CRAFT MOLD BROWN BAG COOKIE...

$15.00 USD

Lots of plastic Cookie Cutters, Vintage, RARE - #12
USA
Lots of plastic Cookie Cutters,...

$30.00 USD

Lots of plastic Cookie Cutters,...

$30.00 USD

VINTAGE NIB MIRRO COOKY-PASTRY KIT And DECORATOR KITS NIB NEW M-0358-22 M-0360
USA
VINTAGE NIB MIRRO COOKY-PASTRY KIT...

$69.99 USD

VINTAGE NIB MIRRO COOKY-PASTRY KIT...

$69.99 USD

Vintage Mirro Aluminum & Copper Dial-A-Cookie Press Kit 3 Dial Design Discs
USA
Vintage Mirro Aluminum & Copper...

$35.19 USD

Vintage Mirro Aluminum & Copper...

$35.19 USD

Lot of 89 Cookie Cutters Vintage, Wilton Barbie Holiday Williams Sonoma Copper +
USA
Lot of 89 Cookie Cutters Vintage,...

$32.53 USD

Lot of 89 Cookie Cutters Vintage,...

$32.53 USD