Shop by Department
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor

Cookie Cutters | Surplus Network

1970s AUNT CHICK’S Happy Days & Merry Xmas COOKIE CUTTERS in Original Boxes
USA
1970s AUNT CHICK’S Happy Days &...

$30.00 USD

1970s AUNT CHICK’S Happy Days &...

$30.00 USD

Aunt Chicks Cookies Cutters W/ Instructions And Swiftning Shortening Ad
USA
Aunt Chicks Cookies Cutters W/...

$24.99 USD

Aunt Chicks Cookies Cutters W/...

$24.99 USD

Vtg 1950s Aunt Chick
USA
Vtg 1950s Aunt Chick's Christmas...

$24.99 USD

Vtg 1950s Aunt Chick's Christmas...

$24.99 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter Yellow Baby Booties Sandwich Press 2.5x3"
USA
Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$4.25 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$4.25 USD

Vintage E. Firme Christmas Reindeer 5" Tin Cookie Cutter Holiday Rustic
USA
Vintage E. Firme Christmas Reindeer...

$15.95 USD

Vintage E. Firme Christmas Reindeer...

$15.95 USD

4 Cookie Cutters Molds Vintage Aluminum Green Wood Handles Flower Heart Diamond
USA
4 Cookie Cutters Molds Vintage...

$9.92 USD

4 Cookie Cutters Molds Vintage...

$9.92 USD

10 Large 5 1/2" Metal COPPER NUMBERS Molds with Hangers (4A)
USA
10 Large 5 1/2" Metal COPPER NUMBERS ...

$9.99 USD

10 Large 5 1/2" Metal COPPER NUMBERS ...

$9.99 USD

Wilton Metal Holiday Cookie Cutter 12 piece Mini Christmas Set 2308-1250
USA
Wilton Metal Holiday Cookie Cutter 12...

$9.99 USD

Wilton Metal Holiday Cookie Cutter 12...

$9.99 USD

Vintage Lot Plastic McDonald’s Cookie Cutters Ronald McDonald Grimace Halloween
USA
Vintage Lot Plastic McDonald’s...

$9.99 USD

Vintage Lot Plastic McDonald’s...

$9.99 USD

VINTAGE HALLARK PLASTIC COOKIE CUTTER LOT - SANTA CLAUS SNOWMAN BELL & PUMPKIN
USA
VINTAGE HALLARK PLASTIC COOKIE CUTTER...

$9.99 USD

VINTAGE HALLARK PLASTIC COOKIE CUTTER...

$9.99 USD

Vintage Walt Disney Mickey Mouse Head Red Plastic Cookie Cutter Sandwich Press
USA
Vintage Walt Disney Mickey Mouse Head...

$5.10 USD

Vintage Walt Disney Mickey Mouse Head...

$5.10 USD

Vintage Assorted Metal Cookie Cutters And Biscuit Rounds Mixed Lot of 20 Pre-Own
USA
Vintage Assorted Metal Cookie Cutters...

$12.99 USD

Vintage Assorted Metal Cookie Cutters...

$12.99 USD

NEW 6” Solid Copper Moose Cookie Cutter
USA
NEW 6” Solid Copper Moose Cookie...

$12.99 USD

NEW 6” Solid Copper Moose Cookie...

$12.99 USD

Vintage Red Cookie Cutters HRM - Christmas Bells, Santa Face & Santa - Set of 3
USA
Vintage Red Cookie Cutters HRM -...

$9.00 USD

Vintage Red Cookie Cutters HRM -...

$9.00 USD

2.5" KREAMER TIN BISCUIT CUTTER Tin Advertising Kitchen Tool Primitive Antique
USA
2.5" KREAMER TIN BISCUIT CUTTER Tin...

$8.00 USD

2.5" KREAMER TIN BISCUIT CUTTER Tin...

$8.00 USD

14 Plastic Cookie Cutters Holidays Hallmark Tupperware Unbranded Turkey Ghost
USA
14 Plastic Cookie Cutters Holidays...

$8.00 USD

14 Plastic Cookie Cutters Holidays...

$8.00 USD

Baby Shower Cookie Cutter (14 of 16 pcs.) spells BABY Original Box Baking
USA
Baby Shower Cookie Cutter (14 of 16...

$8.00 USD

Baby Shower Cookie Cutter (14 of 16...

$8.00 USD

Lot of Vintage Copper Tone Metal Cookie Cutters Christmas & more
USA
Lot of Vintage Copper Tone Metal...

$18.95 USD

Lot of Vintage Copper Tone Metal...

$18.95 USD

Large Daisy/Sun Flower Copper Cookie Cutter - 5 3/8" x 5 3/8" x1 1/8"-Excellent
USA
Large Daisy/Sun Flower Copper Cookie...

$10.75 USD

Large Daisy/Sun Flower Copper Cookie...

$10.75 USD

Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutter Lamb Sheep White
USA
Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutter Lamb...

$2.99 USD

Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutter Lamb...

$2.99 USD

VTG Tupperware Porky Pig Three Pigs Cartoon Cookie Cutter Mold Red Plastic USA
USA
VTG Tupperware Porky Pig Three Pigs...

$2.99 USD

VTG Tupperware Porky Pig Three Pigs...

$2.99 USD

VTG Mirro Aluminum Cookie Cutter Mold Lion Zoo Circus King Of Beasts Leo Mascot
USA
VTG Mirro Aluminum Cookie Cutter Mold...

$2.99 USD

VTG Mirro Aluminum Cookie Cutter Mold...

$2.99 USD

Lot 4 Christmas Metal Cookie Cutters Crafts Decor Handle Patina Oxidation
USA
Lot 4 Christmas Metal Cookie Cutters...

$2.99 USD

Lot 4 Christmas Metal Cookie Cutters...

$2.99 USD

Vintage Cookie Cutters Lot Of 64~ Wilton, Disney, Tupperware, Hallmark
USA
Vintage Cookie Cutters Lot Of 64~...

$29.99 USD

Vintage Cookie Cutters Lot Of 64~...

$29.99 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter Panda Bear Teddy Bear Sandwich Press 4"
USA
Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$8.49 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$8.49 USD

Aunt Chicks Vintage Red Plastic Cookie Cutter - Circus Clown Face Birthday
USA
Aunt Chicks Vintage Red Plastic...

$6.49 USD

Aunt Chicks Vintage Red Plastic...

$6.49 USD

Vintage Martha Stewart by Mail Large Copper Nutcracker Cookie Cutter RARE!!! B
USA
Vintage Martha Stewart by Mail Large...

$149.99 USD

Vintage Martha Stewart by Mail Large...

$149.99 USD

Braman Baby Bottle Copper Cookie Cutter - 4 5/8" x 2 1/4" x 1 1/8" - Excellent
USA
Braman Baby Bottle Copper Cookie...

$11.50 USD

Braman Baby Bottle Copper Cookie...

$11.50 USD

Large Monarch Butterfly Copper Cookie Cutter - 5" X 5 1/2" X 1" - Rolled Edge
USA
Large Monarch Butterfly Copper Cookie...

$11.00 USD

Large Monarch Butterfly Copper Cookie...

$11.00 USD

Vintage 40s 50s Cookie Cutters, For All Party Occasions, Made Of Metal
USA
Vintage 40s 50s Cookie Cutters, For...

$11.00 USD

Vintage 40s 50s Cookie Cutters, For...

$11.00 USD

Vintage 1980s Hallmark Strawberry Cookie Cutter Butterfly Star Sandwich Press
USA
Vintage 1980s Hallmark Strawberry...

$10.20 USD

Vintage 1980s Hallmark Strawberry...

$10.20 USD

Vintage Walt Disney Red Plastic Cookie Cutter Sandwich Press Heart Valentine Lot
USA
Vintage Walt Disney Red Plastic...

$10.20 USD

Vintage Walt Disney Red Plastic...

$10.20 USD

VINTAGE MIRRO ALUMINUM COOKY CUTTERS **5** ~ NEW OLD STOCK IN ORIGINAL PACKAGE
USA
VINTAGE MIRRO ALUMINUM COOKY CUTTERS...

$7.99 USD

VINTAGE MIRRO ALUMINUM COOKY CUTTERS...

$7.99 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter Number 7 Seven
USA
Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$7.99 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$7.99 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter Number 8 Eight
USA
Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$7.99 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$7.99 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter Number 0 Zero
USA
Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$7.99 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$7.99 USD

Vintage Hallmark Halloween Cookie Cutters Witch Cat Pumpkin Owl
USA
Vintage Hallmark Halloween Cookie...

$7.13 USD

Vintage Hallmark Halloween Cookie...

$7.13 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Mini Teddy Bear Plastic Cookie Cutter Sandwich Press 2"
USA
Hallmark Vintage Plastic Mini Teddy...

$12.75 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Mini Teddy...

$12.75 USD

Vintage 1991 Precious Moments Pink Plastic Cookie Cutters Sandwich Press Lot/5
USA
Vintage 1991 Precious Moments Pink...

$12.75 USD

Vintage 1991 Precious Moments Pink...

$12.75 USD

Vintage Tupperware 1658 Nesting Cookie Cutters 5 Piece Set
USA
Vintage Tupperware 1658 Nesting...

$7.00 USD

Vintage Tupperware 1658 Nesting...

$7.00 USD

Vintage Wilton Farmyard Animals Cookies Duck Sheep Pig Cow Chicken 4H Crafts
USA
Vintage Wilton Farmyard Animals...

$9.95 USD

Vintage Wilton Farmyard Animals...

$9.95 USD

4 Tin Cookie Cutters Quilters Sewing Machine Thimble Scissors Thread Spool 3”
USA
4 Tin Cookie Cutters Quilters Sewing...

$9.95 USD

4 Tin Cookie Cutters Quilters Sewing...

$9.95 USD

Hallmark Vintage Cookie Cutter - Peach Fruit Nature Picnic Georgia
USA
Hallmark Vintage Cookie Cutter -...

$9.95 USD

Hallmark Vintage Cookie Cutter -...

$9.95 USD

Vintage Donut Biscuit Cookie Cutter Removeable Red Wood Knob / Handle
USA
Vintage Donut Biscuit Cookie Cutter...

$9.95 USD

Vintage Donut Biscuit Cookie Cutter...

$9.95 USD

Robin Hood Flour Vintage Cookie Cutter - Little John Sherwood Forest England
USA
Robin Hood Flour Vintage Cookie...

$9.95 USD

Robin Hood Flour Vintage Cookie...

$9.95 USD

Miniature Aluminum Metal Cookie Cutters Animals 1.5" Dog Cat Hen Rabbit Lot of 7
USA
Miniature Aluminum Metal Cookie...

$9.95 USD

Miniature Aluminum Metal Cookie...

$9.95 USD

Lot of 9 Vintage Aluminum/ Metal Cookie Cutters Some Handled, Great Condition!
USA
Lot of 9 Vintage Aluminum/ Metal...

$9.95 USD

Lot of 9 Vintage Aluminum/ Metal...

$9.95 USD

Vintage Disney Christmas 6pc Cookie Cutters NEW Mickey Minnie Holiday Sealed
USA
Vintage Disney Christmas 6pc Cookie...

$13.59 USD

Vintage Disney Christmas 6pc Cookie...

$13.59 USD

Vintage Hutzler Plastic Cookie Cutter - Turkey Thanksgiving Farm
USA
Vintage Hutzler Plastic Cookie Cutter...

$6.25 USD

Vintage Hutzler Plastic Cookie Cutter...

$6.25 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter - Leprechaun Hat Shamrock St Patrick
USA
Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$6.25 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$6.25 USD

Lot Of 20 vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters Various Shapes Animal Christmas
USA
Lot Of 20 vintage Aluminum Cookie...

$19.99 USD

Lot Of 20 vintage Aluminum Cookie...

$19.99 USD

Vintage 1980s Hallmark Cards Valentines Day Heart Imprint Cookie Cutters Love 11
USA
Vintage 1980s Hallmark Cards...

$17.00 USD

Vintage 1980s Hallmark Cards...

$17.00 USD

3 Vintage Animal Cookie Cutters Varied styles and materials, copper tin plastic
USA
3 Vintage Animal Cookie Cutters...

$9.90 USD

3 Vintage Animal Cookie Cutters...

$9.90 USD

Wilton Winnie the Pooh & Friends Cookie Cutters 1994 Tigger Eeyore Piglet &
USA
Wilton Winnie the Pooh & Friends...

$9.90 USD

Wilton Winnie the Pooh & Friends...

$9.90 USD

14 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters All Different
USA
14 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters...

$16.99 USD

14 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters...

$16.99 USD

Primitive Metal Cookie Cutter HEART Ornament
USA
Primitive Metal Cookie Cutter HEART...

$4.95 USD

Primitive Metal Cookie Cutter HEART...

$4.95 USD

Vintage Tupperware Red Plastic Cookie Cutter - Christmas Tree Decorated Tinsel
USA
Vintage Tupperware Red Plastic Cookie...

$4.95 USD

Vintage Tupperware Red Plastic Cookie...

$4.95 USD

Antique RABBIT Primitive Metal Tin Cookie Cutter Vintage Folk Art AAFA
USA
Antique RABBIT Primitive Metal Tin...

$29.95 USD

Antique RABBIT Primitive Metal Tin...

$29.95 USD

Vintage HRM Red Cookie Cutter - Brownie Fairy Tale Girl Scouts Made in USA
USA
Vintage HRM Red Cookie Cutter -...

$5.50 USD

Vintage HRM Red Cookie Cutter -...

$5.50 USD

5 Tin Cookie Cutters Patriotic USA Flags & Whimsical Stars 2” x 3-1/2”
USA
5 Tin Cookie Cutters Patriotic USA ...

$12.00 USD

5 Tin Cookie Cutters Patriotic USA ...

$12.00 USD

WILLIAMS SONOMA Copper Easter Egg COOKIE CUTTER
USA
WILLIAMS SONOMA Copper Easter Egg...

$12.00 USD

WILLIAMS SONOMA Copper Easter Egg...

$12.00 USD

Vintage cookie cutters. Set of 6
USA
Vintage cookie cutters. Set of 6

$12.00 USD

Vintage cookie cutters. Set of 6

$12.00 USD

ANTIQUE TIN SITTING KITTY CAT COOKIE PASTRY CUTTER KITCHEN BAKING TOOL AAFA
USA
ANTIQUE TIN SITTING KITTY CAT COOKIE...

$12.00 USD

ANTIQUE TIN SITTING KITTY CAT COOKIE...

$12.00 USD

Vintage Hallmark Brown Plastic Cookie Cutters Gingerbread Man Boy Girl Family 6
USA
Vintage Hallmark Brown Plastic Cookie...

$25.49 USD

Vintage Hallmark Brown Plastic Cookie...

$25.49 USD

Vintage Multi Color Sealed Christmas Cookie Cutters Plastic Made in Hong Kong
USA
Vintage Multi Color Sealed Christmas...

$10.00 USD

Vintage Multi Color Sealed Christmas...

$10.00 USD

Vintage ELEPHANT Aluminum Cookie Cutter with Green Wood Knob Handle 3"
USA
Vintage ELEPHANT Aluminum Cookie...

$10.00 USD

Vintage ELEPHANT Aluminum Cookie...

$10.00 USD

STAINLESS STEEL FOOD CUTTERS SET OF 4 NEW IN BOX
USA
STAINLESS STEEL FOOD CUTTERS SET OF 4...

$3.33 USD

STAINLESS STEEL FOOD CUTTERS SET OF 4...

$3.33 USD

VTG Angel Cookie Cutter Mold Pink Copper Aluminum Christmas Nativity 5x3x.25”
USA
VTG Angel Cookie Cutter Mold Pink...

$3.99 USD

VTG Angel Cookie Cutter Mold Pink...

$3.99 USD

Lot 4 Christmas Cookie Cutters Powder Coated Gingerbread Snowflake Tree Star
USA
Lot 4 Christmas Cookie Cutters Powder...

$3.99 USD

Lot 4 Christmas Cookie Cutters Powder...

$3.99 USD

horse cookie cutter FREE SHIP equine head cake topper made in USA
USA
horse cookie cutter FREE SHIP equine...

$5.99 USD

horse cookie cutter FREE SHIP equine...

$5.99 USD

Vintage Green Handle Aluminum Cookie Cutters - Lot of 5
USA
Vintage Green Handle Aluminum Cookie...

$13.99 USD

Vintage Green Handle Aluminum Cookie...

$13.99 USD

vintage Pennsylvania Dutch Recipe cards in original box, traditional Amish Foodi
USA
vintage Pennsylvania Dutch Recipe...

$13.99 USD

vintage Pennsylvania Dutch Recipe...

$13.99 USD

Wilton Plastic Cookie Pastry Cutters 1983 Lot of 10 Vintage Yellow
USA
Wilton Plastic Cookie Pastry Cutters...

$14.80 USD

Wilton Plastic Cookie Pastry Cutters...

$14.80 USD

Vintage Steel Texas Cookie Cutter - in ORIGINAL BOX
USA
Vintage Steel Texas Cookie Cutter -...

$5.00 USD

Vintage Steel Texas Cookie Cutter -...

$5.00 USD

4 ANTIQUE TIN BISCUIT COOKIE DONUT CUTTERS KITCHEN BAKING TOOLS STRAP HDLS AAFA
USA
4 ANTIQUE TIN BISCUIT COOKIE DONUT...

$24.00 USD

4 ANTIQUE TIN BISCUIT COOKIE DONUT...

$24.00 USD

Tupperware Nesting Holiday Cookie Cutters with Storage Case + Free Shipping!!
USA
Tupperware Nesting Holiday Cookie...

$6.99 USD

Tupperware Nesting Holiday Cookie...

$6.99 USD

Lot of 8 Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters Red Green Handles Holiday Shapes Dog
USA
Lot of 8 Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters...

$16.00 USD

Lot of 8 Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters...

$16.00 USD

Lot of 41 Copper Cookie Cutters 36 Braman 5 old River Road Christmas Fireman
USA
Lot of 41 Copper Cookie Cutters 36...

$150.00 USD

Lot of 41 Copper Cookie Cutters 36...

$150.00 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter - Thanksgiving Turkey Bird Autumn Harvest
USA
Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$5.45 USD

Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie...

$5.45 USD

Disney Pixar Plastic Cookie Cutter / Mold - Sheriff Woody Toy Story
USA
Disney Pixar Plastic Cookie Cutter /...

$6.75 USD

Disney Pixar Plastic Cookie Cutter /...

$6.75 USD

4 Large COPPER Christmas Cookie Cutters
USA
4 Large COPPER Christmas Cookie Cutters

$40.00 USD

4 Large COPPER Christmas Cookie Cutters

$40.00 USD

Lot of 3 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters
USA
Lot of 3 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters

$11.99 USD

Lot of 3 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters

$11.99 USD

TWO Schultz Peanuts Cookie Cutters 1950 Charlie Brown & 1958 Snoopy Lg Red Heart
USA
TWO Schultz Peanuts Cookie Cutters...

$16.95 USD

TWO Schultz Peanuts Cookie Cutters...

$16.95 USD

Vintage Aunt Chicks Merry Christmas Cookie Cutters
USA
Vintage Aunt Chicks Merry Christmas...

$15.45 USD

Vintage Aunt Chicks Merry Christmas...

$15.45 USD

6 Copper Tone Mini Animal Cookie Cutters Chicken horse cat bunny dog lion
USA
6 Copper Tone Mini Animal Cookie...

$10.96 USD

6 Copper Tone Mini Animal Cookie...

$10.96 USD

9 Vintage Cookie Cutters Wood & Aluminum Red and Green Handles
USA
9 Vintage Cookie Cutters Wood &...

$18.00 USD

9 Vintage Cookie Cutters Wood &...

$18.00 USD

Vintage Miniature Metal Cookie Cutters--Set of Six Gingerbread Men Cat Dutch Boy
USA
Vintage Miniature Metal Cookie...

$6.50 USD

Vintage Miniature Metal Cookie...

$6.50 USD

Lot of Cookie Cutters and Press Pastry over 30 Random Pieces
USA
Lot of Cookie Cutters and Press...

$35.95 USD

Lot of Cookie Cutters and Press...

$35.95 USD

vintage Mason’s tin heart shaped cookie cutter with top handle Kitchen Decor
USA
vintage Mason’s tin heart shaped...

$14.99 USD

vintage Mason’s tin heart shaped...

$14.99 USD

NEAT PLASTIC HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTER JOB LOT PUMPKIN AND SKULL
USA
NEAT PLASTIC HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTER ...

$1.95 USD

NEAT PLASTIC HALLOWEEN COOKIE CUTTER ...

$1.95 USD

Vintage Now Tin Metal Aluminum Cookie Cutters Animal Christmas Cross Angel
USA
Vintage Now Tin Metal Aluminum Cookie...

$9.85 USD

Vintage Now Tin Metal Aluminum Cookie...

$9.85 USD

Vintage ANDROCK VENTED SPATULA kitchen utensil BUTTERSCOTCH BAKELITE "BULLET"
USA
Vintage ANDROCK VENTED SPATULA...

$27.99 USD

Vintage ANDROCK VENTED SPATULA...

$27.99 USD

Vintage Lot 6 Aluminum Cookie Cutters Scottie Dog Lion Horse Rabbit Leaf Flower
USA
Vintage Lot 6 Aluminum Cookie Cutters...

$11.95 USD

Vintage Lot 6 Aluminum Cookie Cutters...

$11.95 USD

vtg MIRRO SMUCKERS Promo METAL Christmas Snowman Holly Bell Cookie Cutters NOS
USA
vtg MIRRO SMUCKERS Promo METAL...

$25.95 USD

vtg MIRRO SMUCKERS Promo METAL...

$25.95 USD

Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutters Christmas Santa Candy Cane Tree Angel Wreath 52
USA
Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutters...

$49.99 USD

Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutters...

$49.99 USD

Lot of 15 Vintage Copper Tone Cookie Cutters - Witch Christmas Gingerbread Man
USA
Lot of 15 Vintage Copper Tone Cookie...

$15.00 USD

Lot of 15 Vintage Copper Tone Cookie...

$15.00 USD

OLD RIVER ROAD LARGE COPPER COOKIE CUTTER EASTER BUNNY IN BASKET
USA
OLD RIVER ROAD LARGE COPPER COOKIE...

$38.00 USD

OLD RIVER ROAD LARGE COPPER COOKIE...

$38.00 USD

RARE NIB MARTHA (OS) BY MAIL - STEWART - LG SNOWMAN & CANDY CANE COPPER COOKIE
USA
RARE NIB MARTHA (OS) BY MAIL -...

$299.99 USD

RARE NIB MARTHA (OS) BY MAIL -...

$299.99 USD

Lot of 3 Threshold Cookie Cutters Santa, Christmas Tree, Gingerbread Man
USA
Lot of 3 Threshold Cookie Cutters...

$13.95 USD

Lot of 3 Threshold Cookie Cutters...

$13.95 USD

Vintage Pillsbury Dough Boy Cookie Cutter Set Diamond Heart Pizza Cutter NOS
USA
Vintage Pillsbury Dough Boy Cookie...

$11.19 USD

Vintage Pillsbury Dough Boy Cookie...

$11.19 USD