First & Main | Surplus Network

First Main Tabby KIT KAT Kitty Cat Plush 8 Inch Orange Sitting Stuffed Animal

First Main Tabby KIT KAT Kitty Cat...

$22.99 USD

First Main Tabby KIT KAT Kitty Cat...

$22.99 USD

First & Main Waffle Weave Baby Elephant Plush Rattle Stuffed Toy Pink Blue Vtg

First & Main Waffle Weave Baby...

$11.19 USD

First & Main Waffle Weave Baby...

$11.19 USD

First & Main Foster Fox Plush Menagerie #5075 Stuffed Animal 14" Excellent

First & Main Foster Fox Plush...

$14.99 USD

First & Main Foster Fox Plush...

$14.99 USD

First Main Angel Bear Plush 11" 1304 Wing Sitting Guardian Toy Girl Women Pink

First Main Angel Bear Plush 11" 1304...

$14.99 USD

First Main Angel Bear Plush 11" 1304...

$14.99 USD

Horse Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Brown Pinto Pony Equestrian First & Main 10"

Horse Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Brown...

$14.99 USD

Horse Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Brown...

$14.99 USD

First Main Tender Teddy Bear Baby Blue Plush 12 Inch 2415 2016 Stuffed Animal

First Main Tender Teddy Bear Baby...

$13.45 USD

First Main Tender Teddy Bear Baby...

$13.45 USD

First and Main Mint Green Sherbet Baby Teddy Bear Plush Lace Hands Feet New Tags

First and Main Mint Green Sherbet...

$12.99 USD

First and Main Mint Green Sherbet...

$12.99 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear #1415 Red 12” Plaid Heart Stuffed Plush Soft Toy

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear #1415...

$12.99 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear #1415...

$12.99 USD

First & Main Plush Graduation Gift Teddy Bear Plush 8" Cubbie Grads Plush NWT

First & Main Plush Graduation Gift...

$12.99 USD

First & Main Plush Graduation Gift...

$12.99 USD

First & Main Cream Blue Softstuff Bear Plush Soft Toy Teddy 2324 Stuffed

First & Main Cream Blue Softstuff ...

$12.99 USD

First & Main Cream Blue Softstuff ...

$12.99 USD

Gorilla Plush First & Main Menagerie Zuma Black Ape Stuffed Animal Toy

Gorilla Plush First & Main Menagerie...

$12.99 USD

Gorilla Plush First & Main Menagerie...

$12.99 USD

First & Main Baby Plush Brown & Pink Bear Silhouette Pillow Stuffed Toy

First & Main Baby Plush Brown & Pink...

$15.00 USD

First & Main Baby Plush Brown & Pink...

$15.00 USD

First & Main Flopple Cow

First & Main Flopple Cow

$15.00 USD

First & Main Flopple Cow

$15.00 USD

First & Main Scraggles Teddy Brown Bear 11" Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

First & Main Scraggles Teddy Brown...

$15.00 USD

First & Main Scraggles Teddy Brown...

$15.00 USD

'Sorbet' Teddy Bear, Easter, Pastel,...

$15.00 USD

'Sorbet' Teddy Bear, Easter, Pastel,...

$15.00 USD

First & Main Black Dimple Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush

First & Main Black Dimple Teddy Bear...

$15.00 USD

First & Main Black Dimple Teddy Bear...

$15.00 USD

First Main Pajama Pal Bear Plush Lovey Security Blanket 12 Inch Stuffed Animal

First Main Pajama Pal Bear Plush...

$8.05 USD

First Main Pajama Pal Bear Plush...

$8.05 USD

First & Main Teddy Bear Plush Sits 8.5 Inch Stuffed Animal toy

First & Main Teddy Bear Plush Sits...

$8.05 USD

First & Main Teddy Bear Plush Sits...

$8.05 USD

First Main Sorbet Bear Plush Pink 14 Inch 1438 Stuffed Animal

First Main Sorbet Bear Plush Pink 14...

$8.05 USD

First Main Sorbet Bear Plush Pink 14...

$8.05 USD

First & Main Melancholy Mel Dog Plush 14 Inch Get Well Stuffed Animal Toy

First & Main Melancholy Mel Dog Plush...

$8.05 USD

First & Main Melancholy Mel Dog Plush...

$8.05 USD

First Main Teddy Bear Plush Presley 10 Inch Stuffed Animal toy

First Main Teddy Bear Plush Presley...

$8.05 USD

First Main Teddy Bear Plush Presley...

$8.05 USD

First Main Green Turtle Secret Keeper Plush 4.5 Inch 1572 Zipper Stuffed Animal

First Main Green Turtle Secret Keeper...

$8.05 USD

First Main Green Turtle Secret Keeper...

$8.05 USD

First & Main White Bear Plush Dena Stuffed Animal Toy 14" No. 1786, Ships Fast

First & Main White Bear Plush Dena...

$7.08 USD

First & Main White Bear Plush Dena...

$7.08 USD

Fuzzy Friends Squeeze and Squish Unicorn Whale Plush Purple and Pink 9 in.

Fuzzy Friends Squeeze and Squish...

$8.79 USD

Fuzzy Friends Squeeze and Squish...

$8.79 USD

First & Main Benjamin Menagerie Bear Plush 12 Inch Stuffed Animal Toy

First & Main Benjamin Menagerie Bear...

$9.86 USD

First & Main Benjamin Menagerie Bear...

$9.86 USD

First & Main Monkey Cutesys 2010 Soft Brown Monkey W/Tail Embroidered Plush

First & Main Monkey Cutesys 2010 Soft...

$4.99 USD

First & Main Monkey Cutesys 2010 Soft...

$4.99 USD

First & Main Penelope Parrot FantaZOO 7" Plush Bird #8444 Green Purple Stuffed

First & Main Penelope Parrot FantaZOO...

$19.89 USD

First & Main Penelope Parrot FantaZOO...

$19.89 USD

First & Main SORBET Stuffed Animal Plush 14” Bear Multicolor Pastel Easter

First & Main SORBET Stuffed Animal...

$18.00 USD

First & Main SORBET Stuffed Animal...

$18.00 USD

First Main Baby Teddy Bear Rattle Pastel Pal Yellow 6" Plush Stuffed Toy Cubs

First Main Baby Teddy Bear Rattle...

$16.00 USD

First Main Baby Teddy Bear Rattle...

$16.00 USD

First & Main Tucker Plush Teddy Bear with Beary Christmas Sweater and Bow 13"

First & Main Tucker Plush Teddy Bear...

$16.00 USD

First & Main Tucker Plush Teddy Bear...

$16.00 USD

First And Main Blue Teddy Bear Baby Dean 2782 NWT 9 Inches

First And Main Blue Teddy Bear Baby...

$16.00 USD

First And Main Blue Teddy Bear Baby...

$16.00 USD

Plush Bear "Tender Teddy" Brown w/ Patch Heart Cuddle Soft 14” Valentines

Plush Bear "Tender Teddy" Brown w/...

$5.95 USD

Plush Bear "Tender Teddy" Brown w/...

$5.95 USD

First & Main Teddy Red Bear Plush Stuffed Heart 10” Buster Bear Valentines

First & Main Teddy Red Bear Plush...

$19.99 USD

First & Main Teddy Red Bear Plush...

$19.99 USD

FIRST & MAIN TENDER TEDDY Cream And Purple Stitched Heart Patch Bear Lot Of 2

FIRST & MAIN TENDER TEDDY Cream And...

$19.99 USD

FIRST & MAIN TENDER TEDDY Cream And...

$19.99 USD

First & Main White Plush Teddy Bear 15” Sitting Dena Blue Eyes Soft NWT

First & Main White Plush Teddy Bear...

$13.99 USD

First & Main White Plush Teddy Bear...

$13.99 USD

"Toodles" Plush Bear Tan Holding A Red Heart With Wings 10" Tags

"Toodles" Plush Bear Tan Holding A...

$13.99 USD

"Toodles" Plush Bear Tan Holding A...

$13.99 USD

First & Main White Dena Teddy Bear Plush 10 Inches With Tag

First & Main White Dena Teddy Bear...

$10.00 USD

First & Main White Dena Teddy Bear...

$10.00 USD

NWT FIRST AND MAIN FLOPPY LONG LIMBO LEGS LANKYDOODLE ELEPHANT PLUSH GRAY

NWT FIRST AND MAIN FLOPPY LONG LIMBO...

$10.00 USD

NWT FIRST AND MAIN FLOPPY LONG LIMBO...

$10.00 USD

First and Main Wuffles Pug Plush 2002 Brown 8 Inch Stuffed Puppy Dog Toy Gifts

First and Main Wuffles Pug Plush 2002...

$10.00 USD

First and Main Wuffles Pug Plush 2002...

$10.00 USD

VTG First & Main “Sebastian” Black& White Tuxedo Cat Plush Stuffed Animal 11”

VTG First & Main “Sebastian”...

$39.00 USD

VTG First & Main “Sebastian”...

$39.00 USD

NEW with Tag - Plush Stuffed 11" Gray Elephant (Slowpoke) by First & Main 1002F

NEW with Tag - Plush Stuffed 11" Gray...

$9.95 USD

NEW with Tag - Plush Stuffed 11" Gray...

$9.95 USD

First Main Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle Plush Purple Pink Glitter Sparkle 7"

First Main Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle...

$12.75 USD

First Main Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle...

$12.75 USD

NWT First & Main Western Horse Rough Wrangler 16" Stuffed Weighted Plush Animal

NWT First & Main Western Horse Rough...

$6.93 USD

NWT First & Main Western Horse Rough...

$6.93 USD

First Main Jingles Blue Giraffe Plush Rattle 9 Inch 2773 Stuffed Animal Toy

First Main Jingles Blue Giraffe Plush...

$7.15 USD

First Main Jingles Blue Giraffe Plush...

$7.15 USD

Rare First & Main "Scraggles" Sitting White Teddy Bear w/Pampered Chef Apron

Rare First & Main "Scraggles" Sitting...

$5.00 USD

Rare First & Main "Scraggles" Sitting...

$5.00 USD

First & Main 9" Jingles the Pink Giraffe Lovey Rattle Plush Toy Stuffed Animal

First & Main 9" Jingles the Pink...

$5.00 USD

First & Main 9" Jingles the Pink...

$5.00 USD

First & Main Cream Blue Softstuff Bear Plush Soft Lovey #2324 Stitched Eyes Gift

First & Main Cream Blue Softstuff...

$24.99 USD

First & Main Cream Blue Softstuff...

$24.99 USD

NWT Gorilla Black Brown Plush Soft Squeezable Stuffy Toy Gift Tag All Ages

NWT Gorilla Black Brown Plush Soft...

$6.99 USD

NWT Gorilla Black Brown Plush Soft...

$6.99 USD

First and Main Teddy Bear Plush Woebegone Stuffed 10” Brown Bear Vinyl Paws

First and Main Teddy Bear Plush...

$12.26 USD

First and Main Teddy Bear Plush...

$12.26 USD

First & Main My 1st Teddy Bear Pink Plush Stuffed Animal 12” NWT Baby Cuddleups

First & Main My 1st Teddy Bear Pink...

$5.10 USD

First & Main My 1st Teddy Bear Pink...

$5.10 USD

First & Main Nubby Baby Rattle Lovey Teddy Bear Plush Toy Pastel Pink Blue 8"NWT

First & Main Nubby Baby Rattle Lovey...

$14.90 USD

First & Main Nubby Baby Rattle Lovey...

$14.90 USD

First & Main Nubby Baby Rattle Lovey Dog Puppy Plush Toy Pastel Blue Pink 8" NWT

First & Main Nubby Baby Rattle Lovey...

$14.90 USD

First & Main Nubby Baby Rattle Lovey...

$14.90 USD

First & Main Zooglies Tiger Plush Toy Jointed Arms & Legs 16"

First & Main Zooglies Tiger Plush Toy...

$15.30 USD

First & Main Zooglies Tiger Plush Toy...

$15.30 USD

First & Main 7 Inch CUBBIE Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal With Ribbon Tie

First & Main 7 Inch CUBBIE Teddy Bear...

$8.00 USD

First & Main 7 Inch CUBBIE Teddy Bear...

$8.00 USD

14" FIRST & MAIN Teddy Bear Regis #1895 Beige Curly Shag Stuffed Bean Tush Plush

14" FIRST & MAIN Teddy Bear Regis...

$8.00 USD

14" FIRST & MAIN Teddy Bear Regis...

$8.00 USD

First Main Huggin Friends Dog Plush 5 Inch 4400 Stuffed Animal Toy

First Main Huggin Friends Dog Plush 5...

$8.96 USD

First Main Huggin Friends Dog Plush 5...

$8.96 USD

First Main Dean Bear Plush Brown 12 Inch Stuffed Animal Toy

First Main Dean Bear Plush Brown 12...

$8.96 USD

First Main Dean Bear Plush Brown 12...

$8.96 USD

First & Main Ginger Tan Cocker Spaniel plush stuffed animal Brown 15in Plush dog

First & Main Ginger Tan Cocker...

$8.96 USD

First & Main Ginger Tan Cocker...

$8.96 USD

First & Main Lil Nubby 8" Baby Elephant Pastel #2163 Stuffed Rattle Toy

First & Main Lil Nubby 8" Baby...

$17.99 USD

First & Main Lil Nubby 8" Baby...

$17.99 USD

First Main Cuddle Me Cody Bear Plush White Red Hearts 9 Inch V1574 Stuffed

First Main Cuddle Me Cody Bear Plush...

$12.95 USD

First Main Cuddle Me Cody Bear Plush...

$12.95 USD

First & Main Plush Red Crab 8 Inches with Original Tags

First & Main Plush Red Crab 8 Inches ...

$6.38 USD

First & Main Plush Red Crab 8 Inches ...

$6.38 USD

First & Main Plush Teddy Bear Scraggles With Heart Sweater 9"

First & Main Plush Teddy Bear...

$10.95 USD

First & Main Plush Teddy Bear...

$10.95 USD

First Main Carrotini Rabbit Plush Bunny Carrot 10 Inch Stuffed Animal toy

First Main Carrotini Rabbit Plush...

$10.95 USD

First Main Carrotini Rabbit Plush...

$10.95 USD

First Main Floppy Friends Zebra Plush 10 Inch 7773 Stuffed Animal Toy

First Main Floppy Friends Zebra Plush...

$11.66 USD

First Main Floppy Friends Zebra Plush...

$11.66 USD

First Main Brown Bear Plush 16 Inch Oscar Ophelia Stuffed Animal Toy

First Main Brown Bear Plush 16...

$11.66 USD

First Main Brown Bear Plush 16...

$11.66 USD

First & Main White Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy with Red Ribbon Bow 14"

First & Main White Teddy Bear Plush...

$11.66 USD

First & Main White Teddy Bear Plush...

$11.66 USD

RARE Chuck E Cheese Jasper T Jowls Jumbo 30" Plush Dog Showbiz Pizza Toy

RARE Chuck E Cheese Jasper T Jowls...

$39.98 USD

RARE Chuck E Cheese Jasper T Jowls...

$39.98 USD

First & Main #1955 JETHRO Plaid Bow Tan Soft Fuzzy Bear 13" Bean Stuffed Plush

First & Main #1955 JETHRO Plaid Bow...

$9.97 USD

First & Main #1955 JETHRO Plaid Bow...

$9.97 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Red Magenta Bear 8” Beanbag Plush Stitch Heart 1415LC

First & Main Tender Teddy Red Magenta...

$11.99 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Red Magenta...

$11.99 USD

First & Main Tan Tender Teddy Bear Plush 12" Brown Stitching Red Heart #1815 Tag

First & Main Tan Tender Teddy Bear...

$19.60 USD

First & Main Tan Tender Teddy Bear...

$19.60 USD

First & Main Dolphin Plush Gal Pals Fantasea DAPHNE 7" Sparkly Plush With Tags

First & Main Dolphin Plush Gal Pals...

$4.00 USD

First & Main Dolphin Plush Gal Pals...

$4.00 USD

First & Main Simpleton Teddy BEAR 12 Inch Plush Stuffed Teddy Animal Toy

First & Main Simpleton Teddy BEAR 12...

$9.60 USD

First & Main Simpleton Teddy BEAR 12...

$9.60 USD

First & Main Floppy Friends 8 Inch Green Plush Stuffed Frog Stuffed Animal Toy

First & Main Floppy Friends 8 Inch...

$9.60 USD

First & Main Floppy Friends 8 Inch...

$9.60 USD

First and Main Tan Teddy Bear Dinky Plush Stuffed Animal NWT Red Bow

First and Main Tan Teddy Bear Dinky...

$10.39 USD

First and Main Tan Teddy Bear Dinky...

$10.39 USD

First And Main Bailey Bear Plush Gal Pals Stuffed Animal Toy Blue Teddy 7" 2017

First And Main Bailey Bear Plush Gal...

$12.00 USD

First And Main Bailey Bear Plush Gal...

$12.00 USD

First & Main No. V2024 Mandy Pink 10" Plush Bear Heart Love You Bow A3

First & Main No. V2024 Mandy Pink 10"...

$12.00 USD

First & Main No. V2024 Mandy Pink 10"...

$12.00 USD

First and Main Gal Pals Chihuahua Dog Pink Purple Bow Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

First and Main Gal Pals Chihuahua Dog...

$12.00 USD

First and Main Gal Pals Chihuahua Dog...

$12.00 USD

First & Main Jellybean Bunnies Plush Rabbit Orange 9" Vinyl Ears Stuffed Animal

First & Main Jellybean Bunnies Plush...

$5.98 USD

First & Main Jellybean Bunnies Plush...

$5.98 USD

First & Main Jingles Blue Giraffe Plush Stuffed Animal Baby Rattle Toy

First & Main Jingles Blue Giraffe...

$12.56 USD

First & Main Jingles Blue Giraffe...

$12.56 USD

First & Main Benjamin Teddy Bear Plush 11” Brown Stuffed Animal Bow #1754

First & Main Benjamin Teddy Bear...

$11.05 USD

First & Main Benjamin Teddy Bear...

$11.05 USD

First & Main Moose Plush 14" Spruced Moose Beanbag Scarf Overalls

First & Main Moose Plush 14" Spruced...

$7.99 USD

First & Main Moose Plush 14" Spruced...

$7.99 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Beige Heart 10”

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear Plush...

$12.50 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear Plush...

$12.50 USD

First & Main Minky Brown Bear Plush Stuffed Animal with Corduroy Paws 7"

First & Main Minky Brown Bear Plush...

$15.06 USD

First & Main Minky Brown Bear Plush...

$15.06 USD

NEW First & Main Very Soft Brown Plush Bear Stuffed Animal Coconut Cocoa & Oatie

NEW First & Main Very Soft Brown...

$13.48 USD

NEW First & Main Very Soft Brown...

$13.48 USD

First and Main plush green Cook-A-Monga Monkey 12"

First and Main plush green...

$15.99 USD

First and Main plush green...

$15.99 USD

First & Main Zooglie Cheetah Brown Tan Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 14"

First & Main Zooglie Cheetah Brown...

$21.58 USD

First & Main Zooglie Cheetah Brown...

$21.58 USD

First & Main Lankydoodle Lion Graduation Plush Brown 2002

First & Main Lankydoodle Lion...

$9.99 USD

First & Main Lankydoodle Lion...

$9.99 USD

Vintage First Main Baby Rattle Stork Delivery Plush 12" Baby Shower Decor

Vintage First Main Baby Rattle Stork...

$9.99 USD

Vintage First Main Baby Rattle Stork...

$9.99 USD

First & Main Inc Plush Moose Moosletoe 12” Lovey Christmas Stitched Eyes VHTF

First & Main Inc Plush Moose...

$39.99 USD

First & Main Inc Plush Moose...

$39.99 USD

First and Main Tan Angel Bear Teddy Bear Plush 11 Inch Wings Tutu

First and Main Tan Angel Bear Teddy...

$5.40 USD

First and Main Tan Angel Bear Teddy...

$5.40 USD

First & Main Sydney Seal Plush FantaSea Gal Pals 10" Pink Stuffed Animal 6193

First & Main Sydney Seal Plush...

$8.99 USD

First & Main Sydney Seal Plush...

$8.99 USD

First & Main Kitty Calico Plush "Mellie"

First & Main Kitty Calico Plush "Mellie"

$25.99 USD

First & Main Kitty Calico Plush "Mellie"

$25.99 USD

First & Main Lankydoodle 10” Cow Floppy Plush Lovey Blue Eyes Long Legs

First & Main Lankydoodle 10” Cow...

$11.50 USD

First & Main Lankydoodle 10” Cow...

$11.50 USD

First & Main Minky Plush Teddy Bear 8" Stuffed Animal Bow Corduroy Feet

First & Main Minky Plush Teddy Bear...

$10.04 USD

First & Main Minky Plush Teddy Bear...

$10.04 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Brown & White Bear w/ Patchwork Heart Lot Of Two Bears

First & Main Tender Teddy Brown &...

$7.90 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Brown &...

$7.90 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy 1815 Plush 2021 With Original Tags Plush Stuffed Anima

First & Main Tender Teddy 1815 Plush...

$10.99 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy 1815 Plush...

$10.99 USD

First & Main Brown Plush Gorilla Stuffed Animal Monkey Ape Chimp Shaggy

First & Main Brown Plush Gorilla...

$2.99 USD

First & Main Brown Plush Gorilla...

$2.99 USD

First & Main MINKIES No. 1284 Plush Teddy Bear Brown Red Bow Gift 9"

First & Main MINKIES No. 1284 Plush...

$16.35 USD

First & Main MINKIES No. 1284 Plush...

$16.35 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear Patchwork Heart Plush Stuffed Animal Tan Brown

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear...

$13.83 USD

First & Main Tender Teddy Bear...

$13.83 USD

First Main Rainbow Birthday Bear Plush Teddy Primary Colors Stuffed Animal 2010

First Main Rainbow Birthday Bear...

$12.59 USD

First Main Rainbow Birthday Bear...

$12.59 USD